Database results:
    examBoard: AQA
    examType: GCSE
    lessonTitle: Review and Practice - Non-verbal Explanations
    
Psychology - Social Context and Behaviour - Language, Thought and Communication - Explanations of Non-verbal Behaviour - Review and Practice - Non-verbal Explanations - BrainyLemons
« Back to Menu 🧠 Test Your Knowledge!

Explanations of Non-verbal Behaviour » Review and Practice - Non-verbal Explanations

What you'll learn this session

Study time: 30 minutes

  • Review the evolutionary explanation of non-verbal behaviour
  • Understand the cultural explanation of non-verbal communication
  • Compare and evaluate both explanations
  • Apply knowledge to real-world examples
  • Test your understanding through practice questions

Explanations of Non-verbal Behaviour

Non-verbal behaviour refers to how we communicate without using words. This includes facial expressions, gestures, posture, eye contact and personal space. There are two main explanations for why humans use non-verbal communication: evolutionary and cultural.

Key Definitions:

  • Non-verbal behaviour: Communication without words through facial expressions, gestures, body language and other visual cues.
  • Evolutionary explanation: The idea that non-verbal behaviours evolved because they helped our ancestors survive and reproduce.
  • Cultural explanation: The view that non-verbal behaviours are learned through socialisation within specific cultural contexts.

🐾 Evolutionary Explanation

According to evolutionary psychologists, many non-verbal behaviours are innate (we're born with them) and universal (the same across all cultures). They evolved because they helped our ancestors survive and reproduce.

For example, facial expressions like smiling or showing fear helped early humans communicate danger or friendliness quickly, which could be the difference between life and death in dangerous situations.

🌏 Cultural Explanation

This explanation suggests that non-verbal behaviours are learned through socialisation and vary between cultures. We learn appropriate gestures, expressions and use of personal space from those around us.

For example, the acceptable distance between people during conversation (proxemics) varies widely between cultures, with some preferring closer interaction than others.

Evidence for Evolutionary Explanation

Universal Facial Expressions

Paul Ekman's research identified six basic facial expressions that appear to be universal across cultures:

😊 Happiness

Smiling is recognised worldwide as showing pleasure or friendliness.

😠 Anger

Furrowed brow, narrowed eyes and tight lips signal aggression.

😰 Fear

Widened eyes and raised eyebrows alert others to danger.

😢 Sadness

Downturned mouth and drooping eyelids signal distress.

😨 Surprise

Raised eyebrows and open mouth show unexpected events.

😬 Disgust

Wrinkled nose and raised upper lip help avoid contamination.

Case Study Focus: Ekman & Friesen (1971)

Ekman and Friesen showed photographs of facial expressions to people from different cultures, including a remote tribe in New Guinea with little contact with the outside world. They found that people across all cultures could identify the six basic emotions from facial expressions, suggesting these expressions are innate rather than learned.

Blind People's Expressions

Another piece of evidence for the evolutionary explanation comes from studies of people who are blind from birth. These individuals display the same facial expressions as sighted people, even though they've never seen these expressions. This suggests that certain expressions are innate rather than learned through observation.

Evidence for Cultural Explanation

Cultural Differences in Non-verbal Behaviour

While some expressions may be universal, many aspects of non-verbal communication vary significantly between cultures:

👋 Gestures

The same gesture can have completely different meanings in different cultures. For example, the thumbs-up gesture is positive in the UK but can be offensive in some Middle Eastern countries. The 'OK' hand sign is positive in Western cultures but considered rude in Brazil.

👀 Eye Contact

In Western cultures, direct eye contact shows confidence and honesty. In many Asian, African and Latin American cultures, prolonged eye contact with authority figures is considered disrespectful. These differences suggest cultural learning rather than innate tendencies.

Case Study Focus: Display Rules

Ekman also identified what he called "display rules" - cultural norms that govern when and how emotions should be expressed. For example, in Japan, it's considered inappropriate to show negative emotions in public, so people learn to mask these with smiles. This shows how culture can modify our innate expressions.

Comparing the Explanations

Strengths of Evolutionary Explanation

  • Explains why certain expressions (like smiling) are universal
  • Supported by studies of blind people who display normal expressions
  • Explains why babies show expressions before they could learn them
  • Cross-cultural research supports universality of basic expressions

Limitations of Evolutionary Explanation

  • Doesn't explain cultural variations in non-verbal communication
  • Some expressions (like sticking out tongue) vary widely between cultures
  • Difficult to prove that behaviours evolved for specific purposes
  • May oversimplify complex human behaviours

Strengths of Cultural Explanation

  • Explains cultural differences in gestures, proxemics and touch
  • Accounts for how non-verbal behaviour changes over time
  • Explains why people adapt their non-verbal behaviour in different contexts
  • Supported by research on cultural display rules

Limitations of Cultural Explanation

  • Doesn't explain universality of some expressions
  • Can't account for expressions in blind people who haven't observed others
  • Doesn't explain why babies show expressions before cultural learning
  • May underestimate biological influences

The Integrated Approach

Most psychologists now believe that non-verbal behaviour is influenced by both evolutionary and cultural factors. This integrated approach suggests that:

  • We have some innate, universal expressions (supporting the evolutionary explanation)
  • Culture modifies how, when and where these expressions are displayed (supporting the cultural explanation)
  • Some non-verbal behaviours are entirely culturally specific

Application to Real Life

Understanding the evolutionary and cultural bases of non-verbal communication has practical applications in many fields:

  • Business: Helps international companies avoid cultural misunderstandings
  • Therapy: Helps therapists better understand clients from different backgrounds
  • Law enforcement: Aids in understanding truthfulness across cultures
  • Education: Helps teachers work effectively with diverse student populations

Exam Tips: Comparing Explanations

In your exam, you might be asked to compare and evaluate these explanations. Remember to:

  • Define both explanations clearly
  • Provide specific evidence for each (e.g., Ekman's studies for evolutionary, cultural differences for cultural)
  • Discuss strengths and limitations of each approach
  • Conclude that both explanations have merit and an integrated approach is most useful
  • Use psychological terminology correctly (e.g., innate, universal, display rules)

Review Questions

Before moving on to the quiz, think about these questions:

  1. What evidence suggests that some facial expressions are innate rather than learned?
  2. How do display rules demonstrate cultural influences on non-verbal behaviour?
  3. Why is an integrated approach to explaining non-verbal behaviour most useful?
  4. How might understanding these explanations help in real-world situations?
🧠 Test Your Knowledge!
Chat to Psychology tutor