Introduction to Durkheim's View on Education
Émile Durkheim (1858-1917) was a French sociologist who is often called the "father of sociology." He was one of the first thinkers to examine education from a sociological perspective. Durkheim saw education as a crucial social institution that helps society function smoothly. His ideas form part of the functionalist perspective in sociology.
Key Definitions:
- Functionalism: A theoretical perspective that sees society as a complex system of interconnected parts working together to maintain stability.
- Social solidarity: The bonds that unite people within a society and create a sense of belonging to a community.
- Social cohesion: The willingness of members of society to cooperate with each other to survive and prosper.
- Collective conscience: The shared beliefs, values and moral attitudes that operate as a unifying force within society.
Who Was Émile Durkheim?
Émile Durkheim was born in France in 1858. He became the first professor of sociology in France and published important works on education, religion, suicide and the division of labour in society. Durkheim believed that education was vital for creating social order in modern industrial societies. He died in 1917, but his ideas continue to influence sociology today.
Durkheim's Functions of Education
According to Durkheim, education serves several crucial functions that help maintain social order and stability. Let's explore these functions in detail.
🏫 Creating Social Solidarity
For Durkheim, one of education's most important functions is to create social solidarity. Schools bring together children from different backgrounds and teach them shared values, creating bonds between individuals and a sense of belonging to the wider society.
📚 Transmitting Core Values
Education teaches students the core values of society, such as respect for others, honesty, hard work and patriotism. By learning these values, students develop a sense of commitment to society and understand what behaviour is expected of them.
How Schools Create Social Solidarity
Durkheim identified several ways that schools create social solidarity:
- School rituals and ceremonies: Activities like assemblies, sports days and prize-giving ceremonies create a sense of belonging to the school community.
- History teaching: Learning about national history helps students develop a sense of shared heritage and collective identity.
- School rules: Following rules teaches students to respect authority and prepares them for following society's laws as adults.
- Team activities: Sports, group projects and other team activities teach cooperation and working together for common goals.
Case Study Focus: School Uniforms
School uniforms are a perfect example of how education creates social solidarity. By wearing the same clothes, students develop a sense of belonging to their school community. Uniforms remove visible signs of social class differences, helping to create a sense of equality among students. Durkheim would see uniforms as a way of preparing students for society, where they will need to follow dress codes in many workplaces.
Teaching Specialist Skills
Durkheim recognised that modern industrial societies need people with specialised skills. Education prepares students for their future roles in the division of labour by:
💻 Technical Knowledge
Schools teach subject-specific knowledge and skills needed for different occupations.
💪 Work Discipline
Education teaches punctuality, following instructions and completing tasks on time.
🤝 Cooperation
Students learn to work with others and understand their role within a larger system.
Maintaining Social Order
For Durkheim, education helps maintain social order by teaching students to accept the norms and values of society. This creates social control in two main ways:
- External control: Through rules, rewards and punishments, schools teach students to follow authority.
- Internal control: More importantly, education helps students internalise society's values so they want to behave in socially acceptable ways.
Durkheim believed that without this moral education, individuals would pursue their own selfish interests, leading to conflict and disorder in society.
From Mechanical to Organic Solidarity
Durkheim argued that as societies develop, they move from mechanical solidarity (where people are united by similar work and beliefs) to organic solidarity (where people are united through their different but complementary roles).
In traditional societies, education was simple and often took place within the family. Everyone learned similar skills and shared the same beliefs. In modern industrial societies, education became more specialised to prepare people for different roles in the division of labour.
🕊 Mechanical Solidarity
In traditional societies, people were united by similarities. Education was informal, took place in the family and taught everyone similar skills and beliefs.
🎯 Organic Solidarity
In modern societies, people are united by their differences and interdependence. Formal education teaches specialised skills for different roles while also creating a shared identity.
Criticisms of Durkheim's View
While Durkheim's ideas have been influential, they have also faced criticism:
- Ignores conflict: Critics argue that Durkheim overlooks how education can reproduce inequality and serve the interests of powerful groups in society.
- Overly deterministic: His view suggests that individuals passively accept society's values, ignoring how people can resist or challenge what they're taught.
- Dated perspective: Some argue that in today's diverse, multicultural societies, there is less consensus about what values should be taught in schools.
- Neglects hidden curriculum: Durkheim focuses on the official curriculum but pays less attention to the unintended lessons that schools teach.
Marxist Critique
Marxist sociologists argue that Durkheim's functionalist view of education ignores how schools reproduce class inequality. While Durkheim sees education as benefiting society as a whole, Marxists believe it primarily serves the interests of the ruling class by preparing working-class children for subordinate roles in the workforce and teaching them to accept inequality as natural.
Durkheim's Relevance Today
Despite these criticisms, many of Durkheim's ideas remain relevant to understanding education in contemporary society:
- Schools still aim to create a sense of national identity and shared values
- Education continues to prepare students for their future economic roles
- In increasingly diverse societies, schools face the challenge of creating solidarity while respecting cultural differences
- The debate about what values schools should teach remains important in education policy
Applying Durkheim's Ideas
When studying education systems, Durkheim's perspective encourages us to ask:
- What values are being transmitted through education?
- How does the school create a sense of belonging and social solidarity?
- How does education prepare students for their future roles in society?
- Is there a balance between teaching shared values and respecting diversity?
Understanding Durkheim's functionalist perspective provides an important foundation for analysing education, even if we need to complement it with other theoretical approaches to gain a complete picture.