« Back to Menu ๐Ÿ”’ Test Your Knowledge!

Educational Achievement ยป Ball on Parental Choice

What you'll learn this session

Study time: 30 minutes

  • Stephen Ball's research on parental choice in education
  • How social class influences school selection
  • The concept of "cultural capital" in educational choices
  • The marketisation of education and its effects
  • How parental choice contributes to educational inequality

๐Ÿ”’ Unlock Full Course Content

Sign up to access the complete lesson and track your progress!

Unlock This Course

Ball's Research on Parental Choice

Stephen Ball is a British sociologist who has extensively researched how parents choose schools for their children. His work shows that school choice isn't simply about picking the "best" school - it's a complex social process heavily influenced by social class.

Key Definitions:

  • Parental choice: The process by which parents select schools for their children.
  • Marketisation of education: Treating education as a marketplace where schools compete for students.
  • Cultural capital: Knowledge, skills and attitudes that give social advantage.

Who is Stephen Ball?

Stephen Ball is a Professor of Sociology of Education at University College London. His research focuses on education policy, social class and school choice. His studies in the 1990s and early 2000s revealed significant differences in how parents from different social backgrounds choose schools.

Ball's Key Findings on School Choice

Ball's research revealed that parents from different social classes approach school choice very differently. These differences help explain why educational inequality persists despite policies intended to give all parents "choice".

🎓 Middle-Class Parents

Ball found that middle-class parents are:

  • More confident navigating the education system
  • Better at decoding school performance data
  • More likely to visit multiple schools
  • More willing and able to travel further for "better" schools
  • More concerned with academic reputation and university prospects

🎓 Working-Class Parents

Working-class parents tend to:

  • Focus more on practical considerations like location
  • Feel intimidated by some school environments
  • Rely more on local knowledge and word of mouth
  • Value their child's happiness over academic prestige
  • Have less confidence challenging education professionals

The Concept of "Circuits of Schooling"

Ball introduced the idea that different social groups move in different "circuits" of schools. Middle-class families often consider a wide range of schools across a large geographical area, while working-class families typically choose from a smaller, more local set of options.

Case Study: London Schools

Ball's research in London found that middle-class parents would travel across the city for selective or high-performing schools, creating what he called a "cosmopolitan circuit" of schooling. Working-class families, meanwhile, typically chose from a "local circuit" of nearby schools. This created distinct educational pathways that rarely crossed.

Cultural Capital and School Choice

Ball draws on Pierre Bourdieu's concept of "cultural capital" to explain differences in how parents navigate school choice. Middle-class parents possess forms of knowledge, confidence and social connections that help them make more "successful" choices in educational terms.

📚 Knowledge Capital

Understanding how schools work, what makes a "good" school and how to interpret league tables and Ofsted reports.

💬 Social Capital

Networks of friends, colleagues and acquaintances who provide insider information about schools.

💰 Economic Capital

Financial resources to live in expensive catchment areas or pay for transport to distant schools.

The "Skilled Chooser" vs. the "Disconnected Chooser"

Ball identifies different types of parents based on how they approach school choice:

💻 Skilled Choosers

Typically middle-class parents who:

  • Research schools extensively
  • Visit multiple schools and ask probing questions
  • Network with other parents for insider information
  • Consider moving house to access better schools
  • Can "decode" school marketing materials

🚨 Disconnected Choosers

Often working-class parents who:

  • Rely mainly on local reputation
  • Focus on practical considerations like distance
  • Feel uncomfortable in some school environments
  • Have limited time and resources for extensive research
  • May feel schools are "all the same" or that choice is illusory

Marketisation and Its Effects

Ball argues that the marketisation of education (treating schools as competing businesses and parents as consumers) has increased inequality rather than reducing it. When education becomes a marketplace:

  • Schools compete for the "best" students to improve their results
  • Middle-class parents use their advantages to secure places at desirable schools
  • Schools in poorer areas can enter a "spiral of decline" as more advantaged families avoid them
  • The gap between "good" and "bad" schools widens

Case Study: School Open Evenings

Ball observed how middle-class parents approached school open evenings differently from working-class parents. They asked more questions about academic results, teaching approaches and university progression. They were also more likely to arrange additional visits and meetings with senior staff. Working-class parents, meanwhile, often felt intimidated in these settings and asked fewer questions.

The "Chooser" and the "Chosen"

An important insight from Ball's work is that school choice works both ways - parents choose schools, but schools also choose students. Popular schools can be selective about which students they admit, often favouring those from more advantaged backgrounds who are likely to achieve good results.

This creates what Ball calls a "double selection process":

  • Middle-class parents select "good" schools
  • "Good" schools select middle-class children
  • Working-class families are often left with schools that others have rejected

Implications of Ball's Research

Ball's work has important implications for understanding educational inequality:

💡 Policy Implications

Ball suggests that parental choice policies often:

  • Benefit those who already have educational advantages
  • Create greater segregation between schools
  • Make it harder for disadvantaged schools to improve
  • Disguise class inequality as simply different "choices"

📝 Exam Application

In your exam, you could use Ball's research to:

  • Explain how social class affects educational achievement
  • Evaluate the effectiveness of market-based education policies
  • Discuss whether parental choice increases or decreases inequality
  • Compare with other sociological perspectives on education

Criticisms of Ball's Approach

While Ball's work is influential, some critics argue that:

  • He overemphasises class differences and underplays similarities in parental concerns
  • His research focuses mainly on urban areas where choice is more extensive
  • Some working-class parents are very skilled at navigating school choice
  • The situation may have changed since his original research in the 1990s

Key Quote from Ball

"Choice emerges as a major new factor in maintaining and indeed reinforcing social-class divisions and inequalities."

This summarises Ball's central argument - that giving parents "choice" doesn't create equality of opportunity because the ability to make effective choices is unequally distributed.

Summary: Ball's Key Arguments

To summarise Ball's perspective on parental choice:

  • School choice is a classed process that favours the middle class
  • Different social groups approach choice with different resources and priorities
  • The marketisation of education has increased rather than decreased inequality
  • Parental choice policies create the illusion of meritocracy while reinforcing privilege
  • Educational inequality is maintained through seemingly neutral "choices"

Ball's work helps us understand why, despite policies intended to give all parents equal choice, patterns of educational inequality persist in the UK education system.

๐Ÿ”’ Test Your Knowledge!
Chat to Sociology tutor