Gender and Social Control: The Basics
Social control refers to the ways society encourages people to follow norms and rules. When it comes to gender, social control shapes how we're expected to behave as males, females, or non-binary individuals. These controls start from birth and continue throughout our lives, influencing everything from the clothes we wear to the jobs we choose.
Key Definitions:
- Social Control: The methods used by society to regulate behaviour and ensure conformity to norms.
- Gender: The socially constructed roles, behaviours and attributes that a society considers appropriate for men and women.
- Gender Norms: The expected behaviours, thoughts and characteristics associated with being male or female in a particular society.
- Patriarchy: A social system where men hold primary power and predominate in roles of authority.
👮 Formal Social Control
These are official ways society controls gender behaviour through laws, rules and policies:
- Laws about marriage and family responsibilities
- Workplace policies (dress codes, parental leave)
- Educational rules and expectations
- Religious doctrines about gender roles
💬 Informal Social Control
These are unofficial ways society shapes gender behaviour through social pressure:
- Peer pressure ("man up", "act like a lady")
- Media representations of ideal men and women
- Family expectations and traditions
- Gossip, teasing and social exclusion
Gender Socialisation as Social Control
From the moment we're born, we're taught how to "properly" behave according to our gender. This process, called gender socialisation, is one of the most powerful forms of social control.
Primary Socialisation: Family Influence
The family is where we first learn gender expectations. Research shows parents often treat boys and girls differently without realising it:
🎁 Toys and Play
Boys often receive construction toys, vehicles and action figures that encourage spatial skills and physical activity. Girls typically get dolls, kitchen sets and beauty toys that focus on nurturing and appearance.
👙 Clothing
Girls' clothing often prioritises appearance over practicality (frilly, decorative, restrictive). Boys' clothing typically allows for more physical movement and durability.
🗣 Language
Parents often use different language with children based on gender: more emotional words with girls, more assertive language with boys. Girls are praised for being "pretty" while boys for being "strong".
Institutions and Gender Control
Education as Gender Control
Schools reinforce gender norms in both obvious and subtle ways:
- Subject choices: Historical steering of boys toward STEM subjects and girls toward humanities
- Hidden curriculum: Unwritten lessons about gender (e.g., boys called on more in science classes)
- Sports and activities: Different expectations for participation and achievement
- Discipline: Research shows boys and girls are often disciplined differently for similar behaviours
Case Study Focus: School Uniforms
School uniforms are a clear example of formal gender control. Traditionally, girls were required to wear skirts or dresses while boys wore trousers. This reinforced gender differences and restricted girls' physical activity. In recent years, many UK schools have moved to gender-neutral uniform policies, allowing all students to choose between trousers and skirts. This shift came after campaigns highlighting how gendered uniforms reinforced inequality and caused practical problems for girls during cold weather and active play.
Media and Gender Control
The media plays a powerful role in reinforcing gender norms:
- Advertising shows idealised versions of masculinity and femininity
- Films and TV often portray stereotypical gender roles
- Magazines and social media promote different beauty standards for men and women
- News media may cover male and female public figures differently
Research by the Geena Davis Institute found that male characters in family films receive significantly more screen time and speaking parts than female characters, teaching children from an early age about gender importance.
Workplace and Gender Control
The workplace continues to be a significant site of gender control:
- Dress codes: Different expectations for men and women's appearance
- Behaviour norms: Assertiveness often praised in men but labelled "bossy" in women
- Division of labour: Certain jobs still considered "men's work" or "women's work"
- Work-family balance: Women often face greater pressure to balance career and family responsibilities
Sanctions for Breaking Gender Norms
When people don't conform to gender expectations, they often face consequences:
😱 Social Sanctions
Informal punishments for breaking gender norms:
- Bullying and teasing
- Social exclusion
- Gossip and rumours
- Questioning of sexuality
📝 Institutional Sanctions
Formal consequences for gender non-conformity:
- Workplace discrimination
- Limited access to opportunities
- Legal restrictions (historically)
- Religious exclusion or condemnation
Challenging Gender Control
Modern society is seeing increasing challenges to traditional gender control mechanisms:
Feminist Movements
Feminist movements have consistently challenged gender-based social control:
- First-wave feminism fought for basic legal rights like voting
- Second-wave feminism tackled workplace discrimination and domestic roles
- Third-wave and fourth-wave feminism address intersectionality and everyday sexism
LGBTQ+ Movements
LGBTQ+ activism has challenged binary gender expectations and controls:
- Increased visibility of non-binary and transgender individuals
- Questioning of traditional gender roles in relationships
- Legal recognition of gender diversity
Case Study Focus: Social Media and Gender Expression
Social media platforms have become both sites of gender control and resistance. On one hand, they often reinforce narrow beauty standards and gender stereotypes. On the other hand, they provide spaces for people to express gender in diverse ways and build communities around non-traditional gender identities. Platforms like TikTok and Instagram have allowed young people to share experiences of breaking gender norms and find support, challenging traditional social control mechanisms. However, research shows that those who publicly challenge gender norms online often face significant harassment and trolling, demonstrating how social sanctions continue to operate.
Contemporary Issues in Gender Control
Intersectionality
Gender control doesn't affect everyone equally. It intersects with other factors like:
- Race and ethnicity
- Social class
- Religion
- Disability
- Sexuality
For example, research shows that Black women in the UK face different beauty standards and workplace expectations compared to white women.
Global Perspectives
Gender control varies significantly across cultures:
- Some societies have strict legal controls on gender (e.g., laws about women's dress)
- Others have progressive policies promoting gender equality
- Many have traditional gender expectations despite legal equality
The World Economic Forum's Global Gender Gap Report measures these differences, with Nordic countries typically showing the least gender-based control and Middle Eastern and North African countries often showing the most formal gender control.
Conclusion: The Future of Gender and Social Control
Gender-based social control continues to evolve. While traditional mechanisms remain powerful, they face increasing challenges from:
- Growing awareness of gender inequality
- Legal protections against discrimination
- Changing family structures and economic roles
- Social movements advocating for gender equality and diversity
- Young people increasingly questioning traditional gender norms
Understanding how gender control operates helps us recognise its influence in our own lives and consider whether these controls promote fairness and wellbeing or restrict human potential.