Sign up to access the complete lesson and track your progress!
Unlock This CourseOne of the most consistent patterns in crime statistics worldwide is the gender gap in offending. Official statistics show that men commit more crimes than women across almost all crime categories. But what's behind these numbers and what do they really tell us about gender and crime?
Key Definitions:
In the UK, men make up about 85% of the prison population. For every 100 people arrested, roughly 80-85 are men and 15-20 are women. This pattern has remained fairly consistent over time, though the gap varies by crime type.
Understanding gender patterns in crime helps sociologists examine how social factors like gender roles, socialisation and opportunities influence criminal behaviour. It also helps challenge stereotypes and develop more effective crime prevention strategies.
Official crime statistics consistently show significant differences between male and female offending patterns. Let's look at some key trends:
According to UK Ministry of Justice figures, men are responsible for around 75-80% of all recorded crime. This gender gap appears across different countries, time periods and types of data collection, making it one of the most reliable patterns in criminology.
Men account for approximately 85% of arrests in the UK. This gap is widest for violent crimes and narrowest for shoplifting and fraud.
Around 75% of defendants in UK courts are male. The proportion rises to over 90% for serious violent offences and sexual crimes.
Women make up just 5% of the UK prison population. The female prison population has grown in recent decades but remains a small minority.
The gender gap varies significantly by crime type. Some offences show a smaller gender gap than others:
Some researchers have claimed that the gender gap in crime is narrowing, with female crime rates increasing faster than male rates. In the UK between 1995 and 2010, the number of women cautioned or convicted increased by 16%, while the figure for men increased by only 6%. However, this 'narrowing' is mostly seen in minor offences like shoplifting and public order offences, not serious crimes. Many sociologists argue this represents changes in policing and prosecution rather than actual female behaviour.
Sociologists offer several explanations for why men appear to commit more crime than women:
Boys and girls are socialised differently from an early age. Boys are often encouraged to be more aggressive, take risks and prove themselves through physical means. Girls are typically socialised to be more caring, compliant and concerned with relationships. These different gender roles may influence criminal behaviour.
Boys are often socialised into a 'masculinity' that values toughness, risk-taking and sometimes aggression. Sociologist James Messerschmidt argues that some men use crime as a way to 'do masculinity' when they lack other ways to prove their manhood (like through a good job or being a provider).
Girls are typically socialised to be more empathetic, relationship-focused and rule-following. Sociologist Frances Heidensohn suggests that stronger social controls on girls and women (like closer parental supervision and expectations of 'proper' behaviour) reduce their opportunities and motivation to commit crime.
Differences in social control and opportunities also help explain gender patterns in crime:
Women traditionally experience more informal social control through family responsibilities and supervision. They may have less freedom to engage in criminal activities and more to lose socially if caught breaking the law.
Men traditionally have more opportunities to commit certain crimes through their work and leisure activities. For example, corporate crimes are often committed by those in positions of power, which have historically been dominated by men.
It's important to question whether official statistics accurately reflect real gender differences in offending:
Some sociologists argue that female crime is more hidden or treated differently by the criminal justice system:
Suggests police and courts treat women more leniently, leading to fewer women in the statistics. Women may be more likely to receive cautions rather than charges.
Women who commit crimes may be judged more harshly if they've also broken gender norms, leading to harsher treatment for certain offences.
Crimes typically committed by women (like benefit fraud) may be less likely to be reported or recorded than those typically committed by men.
Self-report studies, where people anonymously report their own criminal behaviour, still show gender differences but with smaller gaps than official statistics. The Youth Lifestyle Survey found that while official statistics showed boys committing 4 times more crime than girls, self-report data suggested the ratio was closer to 2:1. This suggests official statistics may exaggerate gender differences, though significant gaps remain.
Some important developments in gender and crime statistics include:
The female prison population in the UK has more than doubled since 1995, though from a low base. This is partly due to more women being imprisoned for non-violent offences like drug offences and theft. Some sociologists argue this reflects changing attitudes toward female offenders rather than increased female criminality.
As gender roles become less rigid, some researchers suggest female crime patterns may change. For instance, as women enter traditionally male workplaces, they gain opportunities for different types of crime like workplace theft or fraud. However, evidence for this 'liberation thesis' remains limited.
Gender differences in crime statistics are influenced by a complex mix of factors including socialisation, opportunity, social control and potential biases in the criminal justice system. While the gender gap is real, its size may be exaggerated by official statistics.
When studying crime statistics by gender, sociologists encourage us to:
Understanding these patterns helps us develop more effective and fair approaches to crime prevention and criminal justice.