Sign up to access the complete lesson and track your progress!
Unlock This CourseUnderstanding crime in society requires reliable data, but measuring crime isn't as straightforward as it might seem. Different methods of collecting crime data give us different pictures of crime rates and patterns. In this session, we'll explore the main sources of crime data and learn how to critically evaluate them.
Key Definitions:
Official crime statistics are collected by the police and published by the Home Office. In England and Wales, these are presented in the Crime Survey for England and Wales (previously called the British Crime Survey).
Many crimes never make it into official statistics because victims don't report them. This happens for various reasons:
Embarrassment, fear of not being believed, thinking it's a private matter, or feeling the crime wasn't serious enough.
Distrust of police, previous negative experiences, or believing police won't or can't do anything about it.
Too much hassle, lack of time, no insurance claim needed, or fear of repercussions.
In 2019/20, the Crime Survey for England and Wales estimated that only 40% of crimes were reported to the police and of those, only about 60% were recorded. This means that official statistics might only represent about 24% of all crimes that actually occur! This huge gap between actual and recorded crime is called the "dark figure of crime" and shows why we need multiple sources of crime data.
Victim surveys ask representative samples of the population about their experiences of crime, whether they reported these to the police or not. The largest in the UK is the Crime Survey for England and Wales (CSEW).
Self-report studies ask people to disclose crimes or deviant behaviours they have committed themselves. These are often conducted among specific groups, such as young people and usually guarantee anonymity to encourage honest responses.
This famous self-report study has followed 411 London males since 1961, interviewing them regularly about their offending behaviour. The study revealed that a small group (about 6%) were responsible for over half of all the crimes reported by the sample. This "chronic offender" finding would have been difficult to discover using only official statistics and has significantly influenced criminological theory and policy.
Each source of crime data gives us a different piece of the puzzle. When we compare them, we get a more complete picture of crime in society.
Best for: Tracking reported crime over time, serious crimes and geographical patterns. Used by: Government, police and media.
Best for: Understanding the true extent of common crimes, victim experiences and fear of crime. Used by: Researchers, victim support services and policy makers.
Best for: Understanding offender motivations, minor offences and testing theories about who commits crime. Used by: Criminologists, youth services and prevention programmes.
Sometimes different sources of crime data tell different stories. For example, official statistics might show crime going up while victim surveys show it going down. This isn't necessarily because one is wrong – they're measuring different things in different ways.
When evaluating crime data, always ask these questions:
Domestic violence illustrates why multiple data sources are essential. Official statistics historically showed low rates because victims often didn't report to police. Victim surveys revealed much higher rates but still underestimated the problem because people were reluctant to disclose abuse to interviewers. Specialised anonymous surveys using careful questioning techniques eventually revealed even higher rates. This example shows how different methods can reveal different parts of the same problem.
There is no perfect source of crime data. Each method has strengths and limitations and each reveals different aspects of crime in society. Sociologists use multiple sources to build a more complete understanding of crime patterns and trends. By critically evaluating these sources, we can better understand both crime itself and how society responds to it.
Remember that crime statistics don't just tell us about crime – they also tell us about social values, power relationships and institutional practices. What gets counted as crime, who gets labelled as criminal and which crimes receive attention are all sociologically significant questions that go beyond simple numbers.