Introduction to Marxist View of Family Functions
The Marxist perspective offers a critical view of the family that differs greatly from functionalist approaches. Rather than seeing the family as benefiting society as a whole, Marxists argue that the family primarily serves the interests of capitalism and the ruling class. This perspective is based on the ideas of Karl Marx, who believed society was divided between those who own the means of production (the bourgeoisie) and those who sell their labour (the proletariat).
Key Definitions:
- Marxism: A theoretical framework that views society in terms of class conflict and economic power.
- Capitalism: An economic system based on private ownership of the means of production and the creation of goods or services for profit.
- Bourgeoisie: The capitalist class who own the means of production.
- Proletariat: The working class who sell their labour to survive.
- Ideology: A system of ideas and beliefs that shape how people understand the world.
📈 The Family as an Economic Unit
Marxists see the family as an economic institution that serves capitalism in several key ways:
- Families consume products, driving profits for capitalists
- Parents socialise children to accept capitalism and inequality
- The family reproduces the workforce needed by capitalism
- Women's unpaid domestic labour supports male workers at no cost to employers
💬 Key Marxist Thinkers
Several key thinkers have developed Marxist ideas about the family:
- Friedrich Engels: Wrote about the origins of the family and private property
- Eli Zaretsky: Explored how families act as an "emotional refuge" from capitalism
- Louis Althusser: Described the family as an "ideological state apparatus"
- Contemporary Marxist feminists: Focus on women's unpaid labour in the home
The Family as a Tool of Capitalism
Engels and "The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State"
Friedrich Engels, Marx's collaborator, argued that the modern family emerged alongside private property and class divisions. In his view, the family serves to ensure that wealth is passed down through generations of the ruling class. Engels believed that before capitalism, some societies were matriarchal with communal property. The rise of private property led men to want to ensure their wealth went to their biological children, creating the need for monogamous marriage and male control over women.
Key Text: Engels on Family Origins
"The first class antagonism which appears in history coincides with the development of the antagonism between man and woman in monogamous marriage and the first class oppression with that of the female sex by the male." - Friedrich Engels, 1884
Engels suggested that women's oppression began with the development of private property and the need for men to control inheritance through the family unit.
Four Key Functions of the Family for Capitalism
💼 Reproduction of Labour
The family produces and raises the next generation of workers (the future workforce). Children are socialised to be obedient and to accept authority - qualities that make them good workers in factories and offices.
👩🍳 Unpaid Domestic Labour
Women's unpaid work in the home (cooking, cleaning, childcare) supports male workers at no cost to employers. This "free service" helps capitalism by maintaining workers without businesses having to pay for it.
🛒 Unit of Consumption
Families are encouraged to buy products (homes, cars, appliances, etc.) which creates profits for capitalists. Advertising targets families to promote consumption and materialistic values.
💭 Ideological Control
The family teaches children to accept capitalism and inequality as normal and natural. Children learn to respect authority and private property, which benefits the ruling class. The family also acts as a "safety valve" where workers can release frustrations rather than directing them at the economic system.
🏠 Emotional Function
Eli Zaretsky argued that the family serves as an "emotional refuge" from the harsh realities of capitalism. Workers seek comfort in family life to cope with exploitation at work. This function helps maintain capitalism by preventing workers from questioning or challenging the system that exploits them.
The Family and Ideological Control
Louis Althusser described the family as an "Ideological State Apparatus" (ISA) that teaches people to accept capitalism. Through the family, children learn:
- To respect authority figures (first parents, then bosses)
- To accept hierarchy and inequality as normal
- Traditional gender roles that benefit capitalism
- The importance of private property and inheritance
Case Study Focus: The Nuclear Family and Consumerism
The rise of the nuclear family in the mid-20th century coincided with mass consumerism. Companies marketed products specifically to nuclear families - suburban homes, family cars, household appliances and family-sized food products. Advertising portrayed the "ideal family" as consumers of these products.
Marxists argue this was no coincidence - the nuclear family structure was promoted because it maximised consumption. Each family needed its own home, car, television, washing machine, etc., rather than sharing resources across extended families or communities.
Marxist Feminist Perspectives
Marxist feminists have expanded traditional Marxist views by focusing specifically on women's unpaid labour in the family:
📝 Margaret Benston
Argued that women's unpaid domestic work is essential to capitalism but deliberately undervalued. Women maintain the current workforce (husbands) and produce/socialise the future workforce (children) for free.
📝 Fran Ansley
Described women as "takers of shit" who absorb the frustrations of male workers. Men return home from exploitative jobs and take out their anger on their families rather than challenging their employers or the capitalist system.
Evaluating the Marxist Perspective
✅ Strengths
- Highlights how economic factors shape family life
- Explains the historical development of the family alongside capitalism
- Recognises women's unpaid contribution to the economy
- Explains why governments often promote "traditional family values"
❌ Criticisms
- Overly deterministic - reduces family life to economic factors
- Ignores positive aspects of family life and emotional bonds
- Doesn't explain family forms in non-capitalist societies
- Fails to account for recent changes in family diversity
- Ignores individual agency and choice in family arrangements
Comparing Perspectives
It's important to compare the Marxist view with other perspectives on family functions:
👥 Functionalist View
Sees the family as benefiting society as a whole through socialisation, stabilisation of adults and meeting members' needs.
👨👩👧 Marxist View
Sees the family as primarily benefiting capitalism and the ruling class through economic functions and ideological control.
⚖ Feminist View
Focuses on how the family benefits men through women's unpaid labour and reinforcement of patriarchal power.
Applying Marxist Theory to Modern Families
Despite changes in family forms, Marxists argue that modern families still serve capitalism:
- Diverse family forms still consume products and services
- Children are still socialised to accept capitalist values
- Women still perform most unpaid domestic labour even in dual-earner households
- Family remains a private institution that absorbs social problems rather than challenging the system
Exam Tip: Evaluating Marxist Views
In your exam, remember to:
- Explain the key Marxist ideas about family functions
- Use specific concepts like "ideological control" and "reproduction of labour"
- Refer to key thinkers like Engels, Zaretsky and Althusser
- Evaluate the strengths and limitations of the Marxist approach
- Compare with other perspectives like functionalism and feminism