Multipurpose Dam Projects » Dam Site Selection Criteria

What you'll learn this session

Study time: 30 minutes

The key criteria for selecting appropriate dam sites
Physical factors that influence dam location (geology, topography, hydrology)
Environmental considerations in dam site selection
Social and economic factors in dam site assessment
Case studies of successful and problematic dam site selections
How to evaluate potential dam sites using multiple criteria

Introduction to Dam Site Selection

Building a multipurpose dam is one of the biggest engineering projects a country can undertake. These massive structures can provide electricity, water for irrigation, flood control and recreational opportunities. But before a single brick is laid, engineers and environmental scientists must carefully select the right location. Poor site selection can lead to disasters, environmental damage and wasted resources.

Key Definitions:

Multipurpose dam: A large barrier that holds back water for multiple uses including hydroelectric power, irrigation, flood control and water supply.
Catchment area: The area of land that collects and drains rainwater into a river system.
Bedrock: The solid rock beneath soil and loose surface materials that forms the foundation for a dam.
Reservoir: The artificial lake created behind a dam.

🏠 Why Dam Site Selection Matters

Choosing the right location for a dam is crucial because:

It determines the dam's safety and longevity
It affects construction costs and economic viability
It influences environmental impacts upstream and downstream
It determines how many people might need to be relocated
It affects the dam's ability to serve its intended purposes

📝 The Selection Process

Dam site selection typically involves:

Initial desktop studies using maps and satellite imagery
Field investigations of potential sites
Geological and hydrological surveys
Environmental impact assessments
Social and economic feasibility studies
Consultation with affected communities

Physical Factors in Dam Site Selection

The natural landscape provides both opportunities and constraints for dam construction. Engineers must work with these physical factors to find the optimal location.

Geological Considerations

The underlying rock structure is perhaps the most critical factor in dam site selection. The bedrock must be strong enough to support the enormous weight of the dam and the water it will hold back.

👍 Ideal Geology

Solid, non-porous rock like granite or basalt makes an excellent foundation. These rocks don't allow water to seep through and are resistant to erosion.

⚠ Problematic Geology

Limestone can dissolve in water, creating caves and sinkholes. Fault lines can shift during earthquakes. Porous rock allows water to leak through the dam foundation.

🔬 Testing Methods

Engineers drill core samples to test rock strength. They use seismic surveys to detect faults and weak zones. Permeability tests measure how easily water moves through rock.

Topographical Factors

The shape of the land determines how much water a dam can store and how efficiently it can be built.

🗺 Valley Shape

Narrow valleys with steep sides are ideal for dams because:

They require less construction material
They create deeper reservoirs that store more water
They have a smaller surface area, reducing evaporation

Wide, flat valleys are less suitable as they require longer dams and create shallow reservoirs.

🌍 Reservoir Capacity

The volume of water a dam can store depends on the topography upstream. Engineers look for:

Wide basins upstream that can hold large volumes of water
Natural bottlenecks where a relatively small dam can block a large valley
Areas where the reservoir won't extend into neighbouring countries or protected areas

Hydrological Factors

Understanding water flow patterns is essential for dam planning. Engineers must consider both normal conditions and extreme events.

River flow: Consistent year-round flow is ideal for hydropower generation.
Catchment area: Larger catchments typically provide more reliable water supply.
Flood patterns: The dam must be designed to handle the largest possible floods.
Sediment load: Rivers carrying high sediment loads can quickly fill up reservoirs.
Rainfall patterns: Climate change may alter historical rainfall patterns.

Environmental Considerations

Dams significantly alter river ecosystems and surrounding landscapes. Modern dam planning must carefully assess these impacts.

🌿 Biodiversity Impacts

Dam sites should ideally avoid:

Areas with rare or endangered species
Important wildlife corridors
Unique habitats that can't be recreated elsewhere
Rivers with migratory fish species

Environmental impact assessments identify these sensitive areas before site selection.

💧 Water Quality Concerns

Reservoirs can affect water quality in several ways:

Decomposing vegetation in new reservoirs releases methane
Deep reservoirs can stratify, with oxygen-poor water at the bottom
Water temperature changes can affect downstream ecosystems
Sediment trapped behind dams doesn't reach downstream areas

Social and Economic Factors

Beyond the physical environment, dam planners must consider human communities and economic realities.

Population Displacement

One of the most controversial aspects of dam construction is the need to relocate people living in areas that will be flooded. Ideal dam sites minimize this displacement or ensure fair compensation and new opportunities for affected communities.

Sites in sparsely populated areas are preferred
Cultural heritage sites should be avoided or preserved
Indigenous communities' rights must be respected
Resettlement plans must provide adequate housing and livelihoods

Economic Viability

Dam projects require enormous investment. Site selection must consider:

Construction costs: Affected by site accessibility, local materials and geological conditions
Benefit-to-cost ratio: Will the dam's benefits justify its expense?
Proximity to users: Dams far from population centres or farmland may be less economical
Alternative options: Would smaller dams or different water management approaches be more cost-effective?

Case Study: Aswan High Dam, Egypt

The Aswan High Dam on the Nile River demonstrates both successful and problematic aspects of dam site selection:

Geological success: Built on solid granite bedrock, providing excellent stability
Hydrological success: Controls the Nile's annual floods, preventing both flooding and drought
Social impact: Required relocation of 90,000 people and submerged ancient Nubian archaeological sites
Environmental consequences: Trapped nutrient-rich sediment that previously fertilized farmland in the Nile Delta
Economic benefit: Provides about 10% of Egypt's electricity and expanded irrigated agriculture

This case shows how even well-selected dam sites involve trade-offs between different factors.

Balancing Multiple Criteria

The perfect dam site rarely exists. Instead, planners must weigh different factors against each other to find the best compromise.

Decision-Making Frameworks

Modern dam site selection often uses multi-criteria analysis that considers:

Technical feasibility (geology, topography, hydrology)
Environmental impacts and mitigation possibilities
Social consequences and community acceptance
Economic costs and benefits
Political and legal constraints

Each potential site receives scores across these categories, helping planners make informed decisions.

The Future of Dam Site Selection

As climate change alters rainfall patterns and river flows, dam site selection faces new challenges:

Historical flow data may no longer predict future conditions
Extreme weather events may become more frequent
Water scarcity may increase competition for resources
Environmental concerns are receiving greater attention

Modern dam planning increasingly considers these uncertainties and incorporates more flexible designs that can adapt to changing conditions.

Summary: Key Site Selection Criteria

When evaluating potential dam sites, planners look for:

Solid, non-porous bedrock for the foundation
Narrow valleys with wide basins upstream
Reliable water flow from a large catchment area
Minimal impact on rare or sensitive ecosystems
Low population density in the reservoir area
Reasonable construction costs relative to benefits
Community acceptance and political support

By carefully considering these factors, planners can select dam sites that provide maximum benefits with minimum negative impacts.

🧠 Test Your Knowledge!