Energy Resources and Electricity Generation » Environmental Advantages and Disadvantages of Energy Resources

What you'll learn this session

Study time: 30 minutes

The environmental advantages and disadvantages of different energy resources
Renewable energy sources: solar, wind, hydroelectric, geothermal and biomass
Non-renewable energy sources: fossil fuels and nuclear
How to compare energy resources based on their environmental impacts
Real-world case studies of energy resource implementation

Introduction to Environmental Impacts of Energy Resources

All energy resources have environmental advantages and disadvantages. Understanding these impacts is crucial for making informed decisions about our energy future. Different energy sources affect air quality, water resources, land use, wildlife and contribute differently to climate change.

Key Definitions:

Renewable energy: Energy from sources that naturally replenish within a human lifetime (solar, wind, hydro, etc.).
Non-renewable energy: Energy from finite sources that cannot be replenished in a short time period (fossil fuels, nuclear).
Carbon footprint: The total greenhouse gas emissions caused by an individual, event, organisation, or product.
Energy efficiency: Using less energy to perform the same task, reducing energy waste.

♥ Renewable Energy Resources

Renewable energy comes from natural sources that replenish themselves. These sources generally have lower environmental impacts than non-renewable sources, but they aren't completely impact-free.

♠ Non-Renewable Energy Resources

Non-renewable energy comes from sources that will eventually run out. These typically have greater environmental impacts but often provide more reliable, consistent power generation.

Solar Energy

Solar energy harnesses the power of the sun to generate electricity through photovoltaic panels or concentrated solar power systems.

✔ Environmental Advantages

Produces no air pollution or greenhouse gases during operation
Requires minimal water for maintenance compared to other energy sources
Silent operation with no noise pollution
Reduces dependence on imported fuels
Can be installed on existing structures (rooftops) with no additional land use

✘ Environmental Disadvantages

Manufacturing panels requires hazardous materials and creates waste
Large solar farms can occupy significant land area
Potential habitat disruption for desert ecosystems in large installations
Visual impact on landscapes
Energy storage challenges require batteries that have their own environmental impacts

Wind Energy

Wind energy converts the kinetic energy of moving air into electricity using turbines mounted on towers.

✔ Environmental Advantages

No direct air pollution or greenhouse gas emissions
Small land footprint - land between turbines can be used for farming
No water consumption for electricity generation
Low lifecycle carbon emissions
Quick to install compared to conventional power plants

✘ Environmental Disadvantages

Bird and bat mortality from collisions with turbine blades
Noise pollution for nearby residents
Visual impact on natural landscapes
Requires backup power sources due to intermittent generation
Manufacturing and transportation of large components has carbon footprint

Hydroelectric Power

Hydroelectric power generates electricity by using flowing water to turn turbines, often involving dams on rivers.

✔ Environmental Advantages

No direct air pollution or greenhouse gas emissions during operation
Creates reservoirs that can provide recreational activities and water supply
Long lifespan of facilities (50-100 years)
Reliable and controllable electricity generation
Can help with flood control

✘ Environmental Disadvantages

Disrupts river ecosystems and blocks fish migration
Flooding of land to create reservoirs destroys habitats and displaces communities
Alters water temperature and dissolved oxygen levels
Reservoirs can emit methane from decomposing vegetation
Risk of dam failure and downstream flooding

Case Study Focus: Three Gorges Dam, China

The world's largest hydroelectric dam illustrates the environmental trade-offs of large-scale hydro projects. While it generates massive amounts of clean electricity (about 22,500 MW), its construction required relocating 1.3 million people and flooded archaeological sites and wildlife habitats. The reservoir has caused landslides, altered local ecosystems and potentially contributes to regional climate changes. However, it prevents coal burning that would release approximately 100 million tonnes of CO₂ annually.

Fossil Fuels (Coal, Oil, Natural Gas)

Fossil fuels remain the world's primary energy source, formed from ancient organic matter over millions of years.

✔ Environmental Advantages

High energy density - small volume produces large amount of energy
Established infrastructure for extraction, transport and use
Reliable and controllable electricity generation
Natural gas produces fewer pollutants than coal or oil
Relatively low land use footprint for power plants

✘ Environmental Disadvantages

Major source of greenhouse gas emissions driving climate change
Air pollution including sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, particulates
Water pollution from mining, drilling and processing
Habitat destruction from extraction activities
Oil spills and coal mine accidents cause severe environmental damage
Non-renewable and depleting resource

Nuclear Energy

Nuclear energy generates electricity through controlled nuclear fission reactions, typically using uranium as fuel.

✔ Environmental Advantages

Very low greenhouse gas emissions during operation
High energy density - small amount of fuel produces massive energy
Small land footprint compared to renewable energy farms
Reliable baseload power generation not dependent on weather
Low mining impact compared to coal (less material needed)

✘ Environmental Disadvantages

Risk of catastrophic accidents (Chernobyl, Fukushima)
Long-term radioactive waste storage challenges
Uranium mining causes environmental damage and radiation exposure
Thermal pollution from cooling water discharged to water bodies
High water usage for cooling
Decommissioning old plants is complex and expensive

Biomass Energy

Biomass energy comes from burning organic materials like wood, crop waste, or specially grown energy crops.

✔ Advantages

Can use waste materials that would otherwise decompose
Carbon neutral if managed sustainably
Reliable and controllable generation
Supports rural economies

✘ Disadvantages

Produces air pollutants when burned
Can lead to deforestation if not managed properly
Energy crops compete with food production for land
Lower energy density than fossil fuels

💡 Considerations

Sustainability depends on source and management
Modern facilities have better pollution controls
Works well in combined heat and power systems
Can provide energy storage in solid form

Geothermal Energy

Geothermal energy taps into the Earth's internal heat, using hot water or steam from underground to generate electricity or provide direct heating.

✔ Environmental Advantages

Very low greenhouse gas emissions
Small land footprint compared to other renewables
Consistent, reliable baseload power not dependent on weather
Long-lasting resource with plants operating for decades
Minimal fuel transportation needs

✘ Environmental Disadvantages

Limited to geologically active areas in most cases
Can release hydrogen sulphide and other gases from underground
Risk of triggering small seismic events (induced earthquakes)
May contain dissolved minerals that require proper disposal
Can affect local groundwater systems

Case Study Focus: Iceland's Geothermal Success

Iceland generates 25% of its electricity and 90% of its heating from geothermal energy. The Hellisheiði Power Station, one of the world's largest geothermal plants, produces 303 MW of electricity and 400 MW of thermal energy. While providing clean energy, the plant has addressed environmental concerns by developing carbon capture technology (CarbFix project) that injects CO₂ into basalt rock where it mineralizes and remains permanently stored. This demonstrates how potential disadvantages can be mitigated through innovative solutions.

Comparing Environmental Impacts

When evaluating energy resources, we need to consider multiple environmental factors:

🌎 Climate Impact

Lowest: Wind, Solar, Nuclear, Hydroelectric
Moderate: Geothermal, Biomass (if sustainable)
Highest: Coal, Oil, Natural Gas

💧 Water Usage

Lowest: Wind, Solar PV
Moderate: Solar thermal, Geothermal
Highest: Nuclear, Coal, Hydroelectric

🏙 Land Use

Lowest: Nuclear, Natural Gas
Moderate: Coal, Geothermal
Highest: Solar farms, Wind farms, Biomass crops

Remember that environmental impacts occur throughout the entire lifecycle of an energy resource - from extraction or harvesting, through processing and transportation, during electricity generation and finally in waste management or decommissioning.

The "best" energy resource varies by location, available technology and specific environmental priorities. Most sustainable energy systems use a mix of complementary resources to balance reliability with environmental protection.

🧠 Test Your Knowledge!