Energy Resources and Electricity Generation » Economic Advantages and Disadvantages of Energy Resources

What you'll learn this session

Study time: 30 minutes

Economic advantages and disadvantages of different energy resources
Cost factors in energy production including setup, operation and maintenance
Economic impacts of renewable vs non-renewable energy sources
How energy resources affect employment and local economies
Case studies of economic impacts from different energy projects

Economic Aspects of Energy Resources

Every energy resource comes with its own set of economic advantages and disadvantages. These factors play a crucial role in determining which energy sources are developed in different regions around the world.

Key Definitions:

Capital costs: The upfront investment needed to build energy facilities.
Operational costs: Ongoing expenses to run and maintain energy production.
Energy security: A nation's ability to reliably access the energy it needs.
Subsidy: Financial support from governments to help develop or maintain energy resources.

🔥 Fossil Fuels: Economic Advantages

Established infrastructure: Already has extensive extraction, processing and distribution systems in place.
Job creation: Employs millions worldwide in mining, drilling, refining and transport.
Energy density: Provides high energy output per unit, making transport cost-effective.
Reliability: Can generate electricity regardless of weather conditions.
Lower initial investment: Power plants are often cheaper to build than renewable alternatives.

💸 Fossil Fuels: Economic Disadvantages

Price volatility: Costs can fluctuate dramatically based on global markets.
Resource depletion: Limited supplies mean increasing extraction costs over time.
External costs: Health and environmental damage not reflected in market prices.
Import dependency: Many countries must import fossil fuels, affecting trade balances.
Future uncertainty: Carbon taxes and climate policies may increase costs.

Nuclear Energy: Economic Considerations

Nuclear energy presents a unique economic profile with extremely high upfront costs but relatively low operational expenses.

☢ Nuclear Energy: Economic Advantages

Low fuel costs: Uranium is relatively inexpensive compared to the energy it produces.
Long-term operation: Plants typically run for 40-60 years, providing stable returns.
High reliability: 90%+ capacity factor, operating nearly continuously.
Energy independence: Reduces reliance on imported fossil fuels.
Low carbon emissions: Avoids carbon taxes and meets climate targets.

💲 Nuclear Energy: Economic Disadvantages

Massive capital costs: New plants cost £20+ billion and take 10+ years to build.
Decommissioning expenses: Closing plants safely costs billions over decades.
Waste management: Storing radioactive waste requires long-term funding.
Insurance and safety: Extensive safety systems and insurance requirements add costs.
Public opposition: Can delay projects and increase expenses.

Renewable Energy Economics

Renewable energy sources have transformed dramatically in recent years, with rapidly falling costs changing their economic profile.

☀ Solar Energy

Advantages:

Costs fallen by 90% since 2010
Zero fuel costs
Minimal maintenance
Scalable (from home to utility)

Disadvantages:

Land use costs
Storage needed for 24/7 supply
Initial installation costs

🌬 Wind Energy

Advantages:

Lowest cost electricity in many regions
No fuel expenses
Quick construction (12-18 months)
Creates rural income

Disadvantages:

Intermittent generation
Grid connection costs
Maintenance in harsh conditions

💦 Hydroelectric Power

Advantages:

Very long lifespan (50-100 years)
Lowest operational costs
Multi-purpose benefits (flood control, irrigation)
Energy storage capability

Disadvantages:

Enormous upfront investment
Long construction period
Displacement costs

Employment and Local Economic Impacts

Different energy resources create varying types of jobs and economic opportunities for communities.

👷 Employment Patterns

Fossil fuels: Historically high employment, but increasingly automated. Coal mining jobs have declined by over 75% in the UK since the 1980s despite continued coal use.
Nuclear: Creates high-skilled, well-paid jobs but in smaller numbers. A typical 1GW plant employs 400-700 people during operation.
Solar: Labour-intensive installation creates many short-term jobs. In 2020, solar employed more people globally than oil, gas and coal combined.
Wind: Manufacturing and maintenance create diverse job types. Offshore wind creates 2-3 times more jobs per megawatt than fossil fuels.

🏠 Community Economic Impacts

Resource extraction: Can create "boom and bust" cycles in local economies.
Renewable energy: Often provides steady income to rural landowners through leases.
Tourism impacts: Some energy facilities (like large dams) can attract tourists, while others may deter them.
Property values: Can be affected positively or negatively depending on the energy source.
Tax revenue: Energy facilities often provide significant local tax income.

Government Support and Subsidies

Almost all energy sources receive some form of government support, which affects their economic viability.

Energy subsidies take many forms:

Direct payments: Cash given to producers or consumers
Tax breaks: Reduced taxes for certain energy activities
Price supports: Guarantees for minimum energy prices
Research funding: Government-sponsored technology development
Risk insurance: Government coverage of certain liability risks

The International Energy Agency estimates that fossil fuels received £440 billion in direct subsidies globally in 2022, compared to £150 billion for all renewable energy sources. However, these figures don't include indirect subsidies like healthcare costs from pollution or climate change impacts.

Case Study: Hinkley Point C Nuclear Power Station

This UK nuclear project highlights the complex economics of large energy projects:

Construction cost: Initially £16 billion in 2012, now estimated at £25-26 billion
Government support: 35-year "Contract for Difference" guaranteeing £92.50 per MWh (in 2012 prices), roughly double the current wholesale electricity price
Economic benefits: Expected to create 25,000 construction jobs and 900 permanent positions
Local impact: £1.5 billion in contracts to South West businesses
Timeline: Originally planned to open in 2017, now expected 2027 at earliest

This case demonstrates how large energy projects often face cost overruns and delays, but can provide significant regional economic benefits.

Case Study: Hornsea Wind Farm

The world's largest offshore wind farm off the Yorkshire coast demonstrates the changing economics of renewable energy:

Initial auction price: £140/MWh in 2014 for Hornsea One
Latest auction price: £37.35/MWh in 2022 for Hornsea Three (73% reduction)
Employment: Created 2,200 UK jobs during construction and 370 permanent positions
Local economic impact: £4 billion investment with significant supply chain benefits in Hull and Grimsby
Scale efficiency: Each project phase has grown larger and more cost-effective

This case shows how renewable energy costs have fallen dramatically, making them increasingly competitive without subsidies.

Economic Factors in Energy Transitions

As countries shift their energy systems, several economic factors influence decision-making:

Stranded assets: Existing fossil fuel infrastructure may become economically unviable before the end of its expected lifespan.
Just transition: Ensuring workers and communities dependent on traditional energy industries aren't left behind.
Grid modernisation costs: Integrating renewable energy often requires significant grid upgrades.
Energy storage economics: Battery costs have fallen by 89% since 2010, transforming the economics of intermittent renewables.
System costs: The total cost of providing reliable energy, not just the cost per kilowatt-hour of generation.

The economics of energy resources are constantly evolving as technology advances, policies change and environmental considerations become increasingly important. What makes economic sense today may not in the future, which is why understanding these factors is crucial for making informed decisions about our energy systems.

🧠 Test Your Knowledge!