๐ง Test Your Knowledge!
Changing Coastal Environments ยป Soft Engineering Coastal Management
What you'll learn this session
Study time: 30 minutes
- The concept of soft engineering coastal management
- Different types of soft engineering techniques
- Advantages and disadvantages of soft engineering approaches
- Real-world case studies of soft engineering in the UK
- How soft engineering compares to hard engineering
- Sustainable coastal management principles
Introduction to Soft Engineering Coastal Management
Coastal areas are constantly changing due to natural processes like erosion and deposition. As humans, we often want to protect our coastal settlements, but how we do this matters. Soft engineering offers a more natural approach to coastal management compared to traditional hard engineering methods.
Key Definitions:
- Soft Engineering: Coastal management techniques that work with natural processes rather than against them, often mimicking nature and having less environmental impact.
- Coastal Management: Strategies used to protect the coastline from erosion and flooding.
- Sustainable: Approaches that meet present needs without compromising future generations' ability to meet their own needs.
๐ Hard vs Soft Engineering
Hard Engineering: Uses artificial structures like sea walls and groynes. These are expensive, visually intrusive and can disrupt natural processes.
Soft Engineering: Works with nature, is often cheaper, more sustainable and visually appealing, but may offer less immediate protection.
๐ฑ Why Choose Soft Engineering?
Soft engineering is increasingly popular because it's often more sustainable, environmentally friendly and cost-effective in the long term. It also tends to enhance rather than detract from the natural beauty of coastlines.
Types of Soft Engineering Techniques
There are several soft engineering approaches used in coastal management. Each has specific purposes and works best in particular coastal environments.
Beach Nourishment
Beach nourishment involves adding sand or shingle to beaches that are being eroded. This widens the beach, providing a natural buffer against wave energy.
๐ Advantages
- Creates a wider beach for recreation
- Provides natural protection against waves
- Looks natural and maintains beach aesthetics
- Can boost tourism
๐ Disadvantages
- Requires regular replenishment (typically every 5-10 years)
- Sand can be quickly washed away during storms
- Can be expensive over time
- May affect local marine ecosystems
Case Study: Bournemouth Beach
Bournemouth in Dorset has used beach nourishment since the 1970s. In 2006-2007, a ยฃ3.2 million project added 320,000 cubic metres of sand to the beach. This has successfully protected the seafront while maintaining Bournemouth's status as a premier UK beach destination, attracting millions of visitors annually.
Dune Regeneration
Sand dunes act as natural barriers against coastal flooding and erosion. Dune regeneration involves rebuilding and stabilising these natural defences.
๐พ Planting
Marram grass and other salt-tolerant plants are planted to stabilise dunes with their extensive root systems.
๐ถ Access Management
Boardwalks and fencing direct people away from vulnerable dunes to prevent trampling.
๐๏ธ Sand Trapping
Fences made of wood or brushwood trap windblown sand to build up dunes naturally.
Case Study: Formby Point, Merseyside
The National Trust manages dune regeneration at Formby Point, where erosion threatens rare habitats including red squirrel populations. They've installed boardwalks, planted marram grass and used Christmas trees as sand traps. These measures have slowed erosion while preserving the area's natural character and biodiversity.
Managed Retreat (Realignment)
Sometimes the most sustainable option is to allow controlled flooding of low-value land. This involves removing or breaching existing defences and creating new ones further inland.
๐ฟ Benefits
Creates valuable saltmarsh habitats that absorb wave energy and provide homes for wildlife. Also reduces pressure on defences elsewhere and can be more cost-effective than maintaining existing defences.
โ ๏ธ Challenges
Requires giving up land, which can be controversial. Compensation may be needed for landowners and communities might resist the perceived "surrender" to the sea.
Case Study: Medmerry, West Sussex
The UK's largest managed realignment scheme was completed in 2013 at Medmerry. The Environment Agency breached the existing shingle bank and built 7km of new defences further inland. This created 183 hectares of saltmarsh habitat while providing better flood protection for 348 homes. The project cost ยฃ28 million but is expected to save ยฃ90 million in flood damage over 100 years.
Salt Marsh Creation
Salt marshes are coastal wetlands that are flooded and drained by tides. They provide natural protection by absorbing wave energy and trapping sediment.
Salt marshes can be created or restored by:
- Planting appropriate vegetation
- Controlling water levels
- Reintroducing tidal flow to reclaimed areas
- Adding sediment to raise land levels
These habitats not only protect the coast but also provide valuable ecosystems for birds, fish and other wildlife. They also act as carbon sinks, helping to combat climate change.
Cliff Stabilisation
Soft engineering approaches can help stabilise eroding cliffs without using hard structures.
๐ณ Vegetation
Planting trees and shrubs on cliffs helps bind soil together with root systems and reduces surface runoff.
๐ง Drainage
Installing drainage systems removes water that might otherwise destabilise the cliff.
๐ Regrading
Reducing the angle of steep cliffs makes them less prone to collapse.
Integrated Coastal Zone Management (ICZM)
Modern coastal management often combines different soft and hard engineering techniques in a strategic approach called Integrated Coastal Zone Management.
ICZM principles include:
- Taking a long-term perspective
- Considering the entire coastal system, not just problem areas
- Working with natural processes
- Involving all stakeholders in decision-making
- Using a mix of approaches appropriate to local conditions
Case Study: Shoreline Management Plans (SMPs)
The UK has developed Shoreline Management Plans that divide the coastline into cells and recommend one of four approaches for each section:
- Hold the line: Maintain or upgrade existing defences
- Advance the line: Build new defences seaward of existing ones
- Managed realignment: Allow controlled flooding of low-value land
- No active intervention: Let natural processes occur
These plans increasingly favour soft engineering approaches where appropriate.
Evaluating Soft Engineering Approaches
โ
Overall Advantages
- More environmentally friendly and sustainable
- Often cheaper than hard engineering
- Creates or preserves natural habitats
- Visually less intrusive
- Can adapt to changing conditions
- May provide recreational and tourism benefits
โ Overall Disadvantages
- May provide less immediate protection
- Requires ongoing maintenance
- Results can be less predictable
- May require giving up land
- Can be politically difficult to implement
- Benefits may take years to fully develop
Future Challenges
Coastal management faces significant challenges in the coming decades:
- Climate Change: Rising sea levels and more frequent storms will increase pressure on coastlines.
- Economic Constraints: Limited budgets mean not all areas can be protected.
- Competing Interests: Different stakeholders (homeowners, environmentalists, businesses) have different priorities.
- Public Perception: Some communities may resist soft engineering approaches, perceiving them as "doing nothing".
Soft engineering approaches will likely become increasingly important as we seek sustainable ways to manage our coastlines in the face of these challenges.
Exam Tip
For your iGCSE Geography exam, remember to:
- Know specific examples of different soft engineering techniques
- Be able to compare advantages and disadvantages of soft vs hard engineering
- Understand at least one detailed case study
- Consider economic, social and environmental factors when evaluating coastal management strategies
Log in to track your progress and mark lessons as complete!
Login Now
Don't have an account? Sign up here.