🧠 Test Your Knowledge!
Changing Coastal Environments » Case Study - Coastal Erosion Example
What you'll learn this session
Study time: 30 minutes
- The processes and causes of coastal erosion
- A detailed case study of Holderness Coast in the UK
- Management strategies for coastal erosion
- Environmental, economic and social impacts of coastal erosion
- How to evaluate different approaches to coastal management
Introduction to Coastal Erosion
Coastal erosion is a natural process that shapes our coastlines, but it can also threaten homes, businesses and important habitats. Understanding how and why coasts erode is crucial for managing these dynamic environments.
Key Definitions:
- Coastal Erosion: The wearing away of land by the action of waves, currents and tides.
- Longshore Drift: The movement of beach material along the coast due to waves approaching at an angle.
- Hard Engineering: Artificial structures built to protect coastlines (e.g., sea walls, groynes).
- Soft Engineering: More natural approaches to coastal management (e.g., beach nourishment).
🌊 Processes of Coastal Erosion
Hydraulic Action: The force of water being pushed into cracks in the cliff.
Abrasion: Rocks and pebbles thrown against the cliff by waves.
Attrition: Rocks and pebbles collide and break into smaller pieces.
Solution: Acidic seawater dissolves rocks like limestone.
🚧 Factors Affecting Erosion Rates
Rock Type: Soft rocks (clay, sand) erode faster than hard rocks (granite).
Wave Energy: Stronger waves cause more erosion.
Weather: Storms increase wave height and erosion rates.
Human Activity: Coastal defences can affect erosion patterns.
Case Study: The Holderness Coast, UK
The Holderness Coast in East Yorkshire is Europe's fastest eroding coastline and provides an excellent case study of coastal erosion processes, impacts and management.
Case Study Focus: Holderness Coast
The Holderness coastline stretches for about 61km from Flamborough Head in the north to Spurn Point in the south. The coast is mostly made up of soft boulder clay (till) deposited by glaciers during the last ice age. This material is easily eroded by the powerful waves of the North Sea.
Key Facts:
- Average erosion rate: 1.5-2.5 metres per year
- Over 30 villages have been lost to the sea since Roman times
- The coastline has retreated by about 3.5km since Roman times
- Prevailing winds from the northeast create powerful waves
Impacts of Coastal Erosion at Holderness
The rapid erosion at Holderness has significant consequences for local communities, the economy and the environment.
🏠 Social Impacts
• Loss of homes and property
• Emotional stress and displacement
• Community breakdown as villages disappear
• Historical and cultural sites lost
💰 Economic Impacts
• Reduced property values
• Loss of agricultural land
• Damage to tourism infrastructure
• Cost of coastal defences
🌲 Environmental Impacts
• Changes to coastal habitats
• Sediment released feeds beaches further south
• Formation of Spurn Point from eroded material
• Cliff habitats created for nesting birds
Coastal Management at Holderness
Different sections of the Holderness Coast are managed in different ways, creating an interesting patchwork of approaches.
🛠 Hard Engineering Solutions
Sea Walls at Withernsea and Hornsea: Concrete barriers that reflect wave energy. They cost about £10,000 per metre but protect valuable tourist areas.
Groynes at Mappleton: Wooden structures built perpendicular to the shore to trap sediment and build up beaches. They cost around £5,000 each.
Rock Armour at Mappleton: Large boulders placed at the cliff base to absorb wave energy. This cost £2 million when installed in 1991.
🌿 Soft Engineering Solutions
Beach Nourishment: Adding sand and shingle to beaches to absorb wave energy.
Managed Retreat: Allowing some areas to erode naturally, like at Skipsea where properties are gradually being abandoned.
Cliff Regrading: Reducing the angle of cliffs to increase stability.
The Mappleton Case Study
Mappleton is a small village on the Holderness Coast with about 50 houses and a population of around 120. In the early 1990s, it was under serious threat from coastal erosion.
Mappleton's Coastal Defences
In 1991, the East Riding of Yorkshire Council spent £2 million on coastal defences to protect Mappleton and the B1242 coastal road, which was only 50 metres from the cliff edge.
The defences included:
- Two rock groynes extending 70 metres into the sea
- Rock armour (large boulders) at the cliff base
- Cliff regrading to reduce the angle
Results:
- The village and road were successfully protected
- Beaches built up between the groynes, providing further protection
- However, areas south of Mappleton experienced increased erosion rates (up to 10 metres per year) due to interrupted longshore drift - a clear example of "terminal groyne syndrome"
Conflicts and Controversies
Coastal management often creates winners and losers, leading to conflicts between different stakeholders.
⚖ The Mappleton Controversy
After the Mappleton defences were built, farmers south of the village took the council to court, claiming that the defences had accelerated erosion of their land. Although they lost the case, it highlighted the difficult decisions involved in coastal management.
This raises important questions about who should pay for protection and whether it's fair to protect some areas at the expense of others.
📝 Shoreline Management Plans
The UK government has developed Shoreline Management Plans (SMPs) to manage coastlines in a more coordinated way. For the Holderness Coast, the plan divides the coastline into sections with different management approaches:
Hold the line: Defend at all costs (major towns like Hornsea)
Managed realignment: Limited intervention
No active intervention: Let nature take its course (rural areas)
Evaluating Coastal Management Approaches
When studying coastal erosion case studies, it's important to evaluate the effectiveness of different management strategies.
✅ Advantages of Hard Engineering
• Provides immediate and visible protection
• Can protect high-value developments and infrastructure
• Often popular with local residents who feel more secure
• Can have a long lifespan if properly maintained
❌ Disadvantages of Hard Engineering
• Very expensive to build and maintain
• Can look unattractive and harm tourism
• Often causes increased erosion elsewhere (terminal groyne syndrome)
• Disrupts natural processes and can damage habitats
Sustainable Approaches for the Future
As climate change leads to rising sea levels and more frequent storms, coastal erosion is likely to accelerate. This has led to a shift towards more sustainable and integrated approaches.
Future Management at Holderness
The latest Shoreline Management Plan for Holderness recognises that defending the entire coastline is neither economically viable nor environmentally sustainable. Key aspects include:
- Adaptation: Helping communities adapt to coastal change rather than always fighting against it
- Property Relocation: Schemes to help people move away from high-risk areas
- Selective Protection: Focusing defences on areas with the highest population or economic value
- Natural Processes: Working with natural processes rather than against them
This approach acknowledges that some land loss is inevitable but aims to manage it in a way that minimises harm to communities and the environment.
Exam Tips for Coastal Erosion Case Studies
When writing about coastal erosion in your iGCSE Geography exam, remember these key points:
- Name specific locations within your case study (e.g., Mappleton, Hornsea, Withernsea)
- Include specific data and statistics (erosion rates, costs of defences, etc.)
- Discuss both physical processes and human responses
- Consider different perspectives (local residents, farmers, government, environmentalists)
- Evaluate the effectiveness of management strategies
- Link to wider concepts like sustainability and climate change
The Holderness Coast provides an excellent case study because it demonstrates various erosion processes, management strategies and conflicts between different stakeholders. By understanding this example in detail, you'll be well-prepared to answer questions on coastal erosion in your exam.
Log in to track your progress and mark lessons as complete!
Login Now
Don't have an account? Sign up here.