Sign up to access the complete lesson and track your progress!
Unlock This CourseTwin studies are one of the most powerful tools psychologists use to understand whether our behaviour comes from our genes (nature) or our environment (nurture). When it comes to prosocial behaviour - like helping others, sharing and showing kindness - twin studies help us work out how much of these good behaviours are built into our DNA versus learned from our experiences.
Key Definitions:
Identical twins are like natural clones - they have exactly the same genetic makeup. If they show similar prosocial behaviours despite different environments, this suggests genes play a big role. Think of famous identical twins who were separated at birth but still ended up with similar personalities and behaviours!
Fraternal twins are just like regular brothers and sisters who happened to share the same womb. They share about half their genes, just like any siblings. Comparing them to identical twins helps researchers work out how much genes matter versus environment.
The logic behind twin studies is brilliantly simple. Both types of twins usually share the same environment - same parents, same home, same school, same neighbourhood. But they differ in how much DNA they share. By comparing how similar MZ twins are to how similar DZ twins are, researchers can calculate how much genes contribute to prosocial behaviour.
Researchers use a special formula called heritability to work out the genetic contribution. If MZ twins are much more similar than DZ twins in their prosocial behaviour, this suggests genes are important. If both types of twins are equally similar, environment is probably more important.
Researchers measure prosocial behaviours in both MZ and DZ twins using questionnaires, observations, or experiments.
They compare how similar the twins are within each pair and between the two types of twins.
Using statistical methods, they work out the heritability - the percentage of behaviour that's due to genes.
One of the most famous twin studies followed over 8,000 pairs of twins for decades. They found that prosocial traits like empathy and altruism showed moderate heritability (around 40-60%), meaning both genes and environment matter. Identical twins raised apart were often surprisingly similar in their willingness to help others, even when they'd never met!
Decades of twin studies have revealed fascinating insights about prosocial behaviour. The research consistently shows that our tendency to help others isn't just learned - it's partly built into our genetic code.
Studies have found that different prosocial behaviours show different levels of heritability:
Heritability: 50-70%
Our ability to understand and share others' feelings shows strong genetic influence. MZ twins often score very similarly on empathy tests, even when raised in different families.
Heritability: 40-60%
The tendency to help others at personal cost shows moderate genetic influence. However, specific helping behaviours are more influenced by environment and culture.
In 2019, researchers studied identical twins who had both become emergency responders. Despite being raised in different cities, both twins showed remarkably similar patterns of risk-taking to help others, response times in emergencies and even similar stress responses during rescue situations. This suggests that some aspects of heroic behaviour might be partly genetic.
Like all research methods, twin studies have both powerful advantages and important limitations that we need to consider when interpreting results.
Today's twin studies are more sophisticated than ever. Researchers now use DNA analysis to confirm twin type, study epigenetics (how environment affects gene expression) and use brain imaging to see how genes influence neural responses to others' distress.
Modern studies use fMRI scans to see how twins' brains respond to others in need. Identical twins often show remarkably similar brain activation patterns when viewing people in distress, suggesting genetic influences on neural empathy circuits.
Researchers now compare twins across different cultures to see if genetic influences on prosocial behaviour are universal or vary by society. Results suggest basic empathy is universal, but specific helping behaviours vary by culture.
The world's largest twin registry in Sweden has followed over 200,000 twins since 1961. Their research on prosocial behaviour found that while the capacity for empathy is largely genetic, actual helping behaviour is strongly influenced by social norms, education and cultural values. This shows how genes provide the foundation, but environment shapes how prosocial tendencies are expressed.
Twin studies have revolutionised our understanding of why some people are naturally more helpful than others. The research shows that prosocial behaviour isn't just about good parenting or moral education - though these matter too. We seem to inherit a basic capacity for caring about others, but how we express this depends on our experiences and culture.
Understanding the genetic basis of prosocial behaviour has important implications for education, parenting and social policy. If we know that empathy has a genetic component, we can focus on creating environments that nurture this natural tendency rather than trying to create it from scratch.
Schools can focus on providing opportunities for students to practice prosocial skills, knowing that most children have an innate capacity for empathy that can be developed through experience and practice.
Parents can understand that while children may have different natural levels of empathy, all children can learn prosocial behaviours through modelling, practice and positive reinforcement.