Sign up to access the complete lesson and track your progress!
Unlock This CourseHave you ever looked at something and been completely wrong about what you saw? Visual illusions trick our brains into seeing things that aren't really there, or seeing them differently than they actually are. But here's the fascinating part - not everyone sees illusions the same way! Your cultural background can actually change how your brain processes visual information.
This area of psychology explores one of the most intriguing questions: are the basic ways we see the world universal, or are they shaped by where we grow up and how we live?
Key Definitions:
Our brains are constantly trying to make sense of the world around us. Sometimes, they take shortcuts or make assumptions based on past experience. Visual illusions happen when these mental shortcuts lead us astray. For example, when we see two lines that look different lengths but are actually the same, our brain is using context clues that normally help us but in this case mislead us.
Before we dive into Bremner's study, we need to understand the star of the show - the Müller-Lyer illusion. This classic illusion shows two lines of equal length, but one appears longer than the other because of the direction of the arrowheads at each end.
Imagine two horizontal lines. One has arrowheads pointing outward (><) and the other has arrowheads pointing inward (<>). Even though both lines are exactly the same length, the line with outward-pointing arrows looks longer. This happens because our brains interpret the arrows as depth cues - the outward arrows suggest the line is closer to us, making it appear longer.
Lines with arrows pointing outward typically appear longer. Our brain interprets this as the line being closer to us in 3D space.
Lines with arrows pointing inward usually appear shorter. This suggests the line is further away from us.
This illusion reveals how our brain uses context and experience to interpret what we see - but not everyone has the same experience!
In 2016, Bremner and his colleagues conducted a fascinating study that challenged long-held assumptions about visual perception. They wanted to find out if people from different cultures would see the Müller-Lyer illusion differently.
Researchers: Bremner, Caparos, Davidoff, de Fockert, Linnell and Spence
Year: 2016
Participants: Two groups - urban British participants and rural Himba people from Namibia
Aim: To investigate whether cultural background affects susceptibility to the Müller-Lyer illusion
The researchers chose two groups that couldn't be more different in terms of their visual environments and cultural experiences.
These participants lived in cities filled with straight lines, right angles and geometric shapes. Think about it - buildings, roads, furniture and even phone screens are full of straight lines and corners. This environment is called a "carpentered world" because it's built with lots of straight edges and right angles.
The Himba people live in a very different visual world. Their traditional homes are round, they live in natural landscapes with curved hills and organic shapes and they have much less exposure to straight lines and right angles. Their environment is much more "natural" and less geometric.
Bremner's team used a clever experimental design to test how strongly each group experienced the Müller-Lyer illusion.
Participants were shown the Müller-Lyer illusion and asked to judge which line looked longer. The researchers measured how much the illusion affected each person's perception. They also controlled for other factors that might influence the results, such as age and education level.
The researchers didn't just ask "which line is longer?" They measured exactly how much longer one line appeared compared to the other. This gave them precise data about the strength of the illusion for each participant.
The findings were remarkable and challenged many assumptions about human perception being universal.
British participants: Showed strong susceptibility to the Müller-Lyer illusion
Himba participants: Showed significantly less susceptibility to the illusion
Conclusion: Cultural environment affects how we perceive visual illusions
The researchers proposed that growing up in different visual environments literally changes how our brains process visual information. British participants, used to interpreting straight lines and angles as depth cues in their built environment, were more likely to be fooled by the illusion. Himba participants, with less exposure to such geometric environments, were less influenced by these depth cues.
Our visual environment shapes how our brain learns to interpret what we see. More geometric environments = stronger illusion effects.
Perception isn't just biological - it's also learned through experience with our cultural environment.
Different cultures develop different perceptual skills based on what's most useful in their environment.
This study has important implications for psychology and our understanding of human perception.
Bremner's findings suggest that some aspects of perception that we thought were universal actually vary across cultures. This challenges the idea that all humans perceive the world in exactly the same way and highlights the importance of studying diverse populations in psychological research.
Much psychological research has been conducted on WEIRD populations (Western, Educated, Industrialised, Rich, Democratic). This study shows why we need to include more diverse groups to truly understand human psychology.
Like all research, Bremner's study has both strengths and limitations that we need to consider.
Cross-cultural design: Comparing very different cultural groups
Controlled variables: Accounted for age and other factors
Practical significance: Real-world implications for understanding perception
Challenges assumptions: Questions universal theories of perception
Small sample size: Limited number of participants
Other factors: Education and technology exposure might also matter
Generalisation: Results might not apply to all cultural groups
Causation: Can't prove culture directly causes the differences
Understanding cultural differences in perception has practical applications in areas like international design, education and technology development. For example, user interfaces for global apps might need to consider how different cultures perceive visual elements.