Sign up to access the complete lesson and track your progress!
Unlock This CourseWhy do some people stick to their exercise routines whilst others give up after just a few weeks? This is one of the most important questions in sports psychology. Understanding what motivates people to exercise regularly can help us design better fitness programmes and help more people live healthier lives.
Exercise motivation isn't just about willpower - it's a complex psychological process involving our thoughts, feelings and social environment. Research shows that people who understand their own motivation are much more likely to stick with exercise long-term.
Key Definitions:
Only about 25% of adults in the UK get enough exercise. Understanding motivation could help millions more people become active. When people understand what drives them, they're 3x more likely to stick with exercise programmes.
In 2010, researchers Calvo, Cervelló, Jiménez, Iglesias and Murcia conducted a landmark study on what keeps people exercising. They wanted to understand why some people persist with sports and exercise whilst others drop out quickly.
The researchers asked: "What psychological factors predict whether someone will continue exercising over time?" They were particularly interested in how different types of motivation affect persistence in sports and exercise.
301 Spanish adults aged 18-65 who regularly attended fitness centres and sports clubs.
Participants completed questionnaires measuring their motivation types and exercise persistence over 6 months.
Used validated scales to measure intrinsic motivation, extrinsic motivation and actual exercise behaviour.
This was a longitudinal study, meaning researchers followed the same people over time. This design is crucial for understanding persistence because it shows how motivation changes and predicts future behaviour, rather than just taking a snapshot at one moment.
The Calvo et al. study revealed fascinating insights about what keeps people exercising. Their findings challenge some common assumptions about motivation and provide practical guidance for fitness professionals.
The study found that people with high intrinsic motivation were significantly more likely to continue exercising over the 6-month period. These individuals exercised because they genuinely enjoyed it, found it personally meaningful, or felt it was an important part of who they were.
Enjoyment: "I love how I feel when I'm running"
Personal Growth: "Exercise helps me become a better person"
Identity: "Being active is just who I am"
Surprisingly, the study found that people motivated mainly by external factors were more likely to quit exercising. This included people who exercised primarily for appearance, social approval, or to avoid guilt.
People exercising mainly to look good often quit when results came slowly or weren't as dramatic as expected.
Those exercising to please others or fit in often stopped when the social pressure decreased.
People exercising to avoid feeling guilty about being inactive often developed negative associations with exercise.
The Calvo study strongly supported Self-Determination Theory, which suggests that lasting motivation comes from satisfying three basic psychological needs. When these needs are met, people naturally want to continue exercising.
Feeling in control: Choosing your own activities, setting your own goals and exercising when you want to. People who felt forced to exercise were more likely to quit.
Feeling capable: Experiencing success, improvement and mastery. People who felt they were getting better at their chosen activities stayed motivated longer.
Feeling connected: Having supportive relationships with trainers, workout partners, or exercise groups. Social connection was a powerful predictor of persistence.
Sarah, 28, started exercising to lose weight for her wedding (extrinsic motivation). After the wedding, she nearly quit. However, she discovered she loved the social aspect of her fitness classes and enjoyed the challenge of improving her strength. By focusing on these intrinsic motivators - social connection and personal growth - she's now been exercising consistently for three years.
The findings from Calvo et al.'s study have important implications for anyone involved in promoting exercise, from personal trainers to public health officials.
The research suggests that fitness professionals should focus on helping clients develop intrinsic motivation rather than relying solely on external rewards or pressure.
Promote autonomy: Offer choices in activities and goals
Build competence: Set achievable challenges and celebrate progress
Foster connection: Create supportive group environments
Successful exercise programmes should be designed to satisfy the three basic psychological needs identified in Self-Determination Theory.
Offer different types of activities so people can choose what they enjoy and feel autonomous in their decisions.
Help people see their improvements to build feelings of competence and mastery.
Create opportunities for people to exercise together and build supportive relationships.
Whilst the Calvo et al. study provides valuable insights, it's important to understand its limitations and consider areas for future research.
The study was conducted with Spanish adults in fitness centres, so the findings might not apply to all populations or exercise settings. Additionally, the 6-month follow-up period, whilst useful, doesn't tell us about very long-term persistence over years.
Researchers could explore how motivation changes across different age groups, cultural backgrounds and types of physical activity. Studies with longer follow-up periods would also be valuable.
The Calvo et al. sports persistence study has significantly advanced our understanding of exercise motivation. By showing that intrinsic motivation is crucial for long-term exercise persistence, this research provides a roadmap for creating more effective fitness programmes and helping more people maintain active lifestyles.
The key message is clear: sustainable exercise motivation comes from within. When people exercise because they enjoy it, find it meaningful and feel supported in their efforts, they're much more likely to stick with it long-term. This insight has the potential to help millions more people develop lasting, healthy exercise habits.