What are the roles and functions of education? » Feminist view - strengths and limitations

What you'll learn this session

Study time: 30 minutes

The key ideas of feminist perspectives on education
How feminists view gender inequality in schools and the education system
Different types of feminist perspectives (liberal, radical, Marxist)
The strengths of feminist views on education
The limitations and criticisms of feminist approaches
Real-world examples of feminist issues in education

Introduction to Feminist Views on Education

Feminist sociologists focus on how education systems can create, maintain or challenge gender inequalities. They examine how schools might treat boys and girls differently and how this affects their educational experiences and future opportunities.

Key Definitions:

Feminism: A range of social movements and theories that aim to establish gender equality in social, economic and political areas.
Patriarchy: A social system where men hold primary power and authority.
Gender socialisation: The process through which children learn gender roles deemed appropriate in society.
Hidden curriculum: The unwritten, unofficial and often unintended lessons, values and perspectives that students learn in school.

Types of Feminist Perspectives on Education

📖 Liberal Feminism

Liberal feminists believe that education should provide equal opportunities for both boys and girls. They focus on:

Removing barriers to girls' achievement
Challenging gender stereotypes in subject choices
Ensuring equal access to all educational resources
Creating gender-neutral teaching materials

They celebrate improvements in girls' exam results and university attendance as signs of progress.

💡 Radical Feminism

Radical feminists argue that education is fundamentally patriarchal (male-dominated) and needs complete transformation. They focus on:

How schools reinforce male power and control
The dominance of male perspectives in curriculum content
Sexual harassment and bullying of female students
The need for female-centred education approaches

They believe schools need radical change, not just minor reforms.

⚖ Marxist Feminism

Marxist feminists see gender inequality in education as linked to capitalism. They argue:

Schools prepare girls for low-paid, part-time work that benefits employers
Education reproduces both class and gender inequalities
Girls are taught to be compliant workers and unpaid carers
The education system serves the interests of wealthy men in particular

Key Feminist Arguments About Education

The Hidden Curriculum

Feminists argue that schools teach more than just subjects - they also pass on hidden messages about gender roles:

Teacher interactions (giving boys more attention and criticism)
School uniforms that reinforce gender differences
Gender-stereotyped activities (boys playing football, girls doing dance)
Gendered career advice and subject choices

Gender and Subject Choice

Despite improvements, feminists highlight continuing gender patterns in subject choices:

Boys dominate in physics, computing and design technology
Girls are more likely to study English, psychology and languages
These choices lead to gender-segregated careers later
STEM subjects (often male-dominated) typically lead to higher-paid careers

Case Study Focus: Gender in the Classroom

Research by Dale Spender in the 1980s found that teachers thought they were giving equal attention to boys and girls, but when recorded and timed:

Teachers spent 38% of their time with girls and 62% with boys
If they tried to give equal time, they felt they were favouring girls
Boys were more likely to call out answers and interrupt
Girls who behaved like boys were often criticised for being "pushy"

More recent studies show this pattern continues in many classrooms today, though to a lesser extent.

Strengths of Feminist Views on Education

👍 Highlighting Inequality

Feminist research has successfully identified many hidden forms of gender inequality in schools that might otherwise go unnoticed.

📝 Influencing Policy

Feminist perspectives have led to real policy changes, like monitoring gender in exam results and encouraging girls into STEM subjects.

🔬 Detailed Research

Feminists have conducted detailed classroom observations and interviews that provide rich evidence about gendered experiences in education.

Additional Strengths

Diverse perspectives: Different feminist approaches (liberal, radical, Marxist) offer varied insights into gender issues.
Practical solutions: Feminists don't just identify problems but suggest practical changes to improve education.
Intersectionality: Modern feminist approaches recognise how gender interacts with class, ethnicity and other factors.
Real-world impact: Feminist campaigns have contributed to girls' improved educational outcomes over recent decades.

Limitations of Feminist Views on Education

⚠ Outdated Focus?

Critics argue that feminist concerns about girls' underachievement are outdated, as girls now outperform boys in many subjects and educational levels.

👨 Boys' Issues Neglected

Some argue feminists pay too little attention to educational problems facing boys, such as higher exclusion rates and lower literacy levels.

🤔 Overgeneralisation

Not all girls or all boys have the same educational experiences - social class and ethnicity can be more significant than gender in some contexts.

Further Limitations

Disagreement among feminists: Different feminist perspectives sometimes contradict each other about what changes are needed.
Focus on schools only: Some critics argue feminists place too much emphasis on schools rather than wider social influences on gender.
Methodological issues: Some feminist research has been criticised for using small samples or being politically biased.
Lack of international perspective: Much feminist research focuses on Western education systems, ignoring more severe gender inequalities in other countries.

Real-World Example: The Gender Paradox

One challenge for feminist theories is explaining what some researchers call "the gender equality paradox":

In countries with high gender equality (like Sweden and Norway), fewer women choose STEM subjects than in less gender-equal countries.
In countries with less gender equality, women often see STEM as a path to financial security.
In more equal societies, people may feel freer to follow personal interests rather than practical considerations.
This suggests gender differences in subject choice might not be solely due to discrimination or socialisation.

This example shows how complex gender issues in education can be, challenging simplistic feminist explanations.

Contemporary Feminist Issues in Education

Modern feminist approaches to education have evolved to address new challenges:

Digital gender divide: Examining gender differences in access to and confidence with technology
Sexual harassment: Addressing online and in-person harassment in educational settings
Intersectionality: Looking at how gender combines with class, ethnicity, sexuality and disability
Global perspective: Fighting for girls' basic right to education in countries where it's still denied
Gender identity: Supporting transgender and non-binary students in educational settings

Conclusion: Evaluating Feminist Views on Education

Feminist perspectives have made vital contributions to our understanding of education by highlighting gender inequalities that might otherwise be overlooked. Their research has led to important policy changes that have helped improve girls' educational opportunities.

However, the educational landscape has changed significantly since early feminist work. Girls now outperform boys in many areas, raising questions about whether gender inequality in education still disadvantages females in the ways feminists describe. Critics argue that some feminist approaches need updating to address contemporary issues affecting both genders.

The most valuable feminist work today recognises the complexity of gender issues in education, acknowledging that gender interacts with other factors like social class, ethnicity and individual differences. This more nuanced approach helps us understand how education can work better for everyone.

🧠 Test Your Knowledge!