Sign up to access the complete lesson and track your progress!
Unlock This CourseInformal employment is a huge part of the global economy, especially in developing countries. While it might seem like a solution to unemployment, it comes with serious disadvantages that affect millions of workers worldwide. Understanding these problems is crucial for IGCSE Geography students studying economic development and labour markets.
Key Definitions:
Informal jobs are those without proper contracts, legal protection, or government oversight. Examples include street vendors, domestic workers, construction labourers paid in cash and small-scale farmers. These workers often operate outside the official economy.
Informal employment creates numerous challenges for workers, their families and entire communities. These disadvantages often trap people in cycles of poverty and limit economic development.
One of the biggest problems with informal work is the lack of stable income. Workers often face unpredictable earnings, with no guaranteed minimum wage or regular pay increases. This makes it extremely difficult to plan for the future or save money.
Earnings can vary dramatically from day to day. A street vendor might earn £20 one day and £5 the next, depending on weather, location and customer demand.
Informal workers aren't protected by minimum wage laws. They might work long hours for very little money, sometimes earning less than £2 per day.
Low and irregular income makes it nearly impossible to save money for emergencies, education, or improving living conditions.
Mumbai has over 250,000 street vendors who face daily income uncertainty. During monsoon season, many earn nothing for weeks. A typical vegetable vendor might earn £3-8 per day, but this drops to zero during heavy rains or when authorities clear the streets. Without savings, families struggle to buy food and pay rent during these difficult periods.
Informal workers have no legal protection against unfair treatment, dangerous working conditions, or exploitation. They can't complain to authorities or join trade unions to fight for better conditions.
Without written contracts, workers have no legal proof of their employment. This means they can be fired instantly without notice or compensation. Employers can change working conditions, hours, or pay without warning.
This lack of protection creates a power imbalance where employers can exploit workers. Domestic workers, for example, might work 12-hour days with no breaks, overtime pay, or holidays. Construction workers might be forced to work in dangerous conditions without safety equipment.
Formal employees usually receive benefits like health insurance, paid holidays and pension contributions. Informal workers get none of these protections, leaving them vulnerable during illness, injury, or old age.
When informal workers get sick, they must pay all medical costs themselves. This can push families into debt or force them to go without treatment.
Informal workers have no retirement savings or pension schemes. They must work until they physically can't continue, often into their 70s or 80s.
Taking time off means no income. Workers often continue working even when sick, which can worsen their health and spread illness to others.
Informal workplaces often lack basic safety measures, putting workers at serious risk of injury, illness, or death. Without proper regulation, employers may ignore safety standards to save money.
Many informal jobs involve significant health and safety risks. Construction workers might work on tall buildings without safety harnesses, while factory workers handle dangerous chemicals without protective equipment.
Informal workers face exposure to toxic chemicals, dangerous machinery, extreme temperatures and poor ventilation. Repetitive strain injuries are common and many develop long-term health problems from their work environment.
Small-scale gold miners in Ghana work in extremely dangerous conditions. They dig deep shafts without proper support, use mercury to extract gold (causing poisoning) and work without safety equipment. Accidents are common, with miners regularly injured or killed in cave-ins. The government estimates that informal mining causes hundreds of deaths annually, but exact numbers are unknown because these operations aren't officially monitored.
The disadvantages of informal employment extend beyond individual workers to affect entire families and communities. This creates broader social and economic problems.
When parents work in informal jobs with low, unstable income, children often suffer. Families may not afford school fees, uniforms, or books. In extreme cases, children might leave school to work and help support the family.
Children from informal worker families are more likely to drop out of school, have poor attendance and lack resources for learning. This perpetuates the cycle of poverty as these children grow up with limited opportunities for formal employment.
Informal workers often can't afford decent housing and may live in slums or informal settlements. These areas typically lack basic services like clean water, electricity and sewage systems.
Without stable income or the ability to get bank loans (since they have no proof of employment), informal workers struggle to improve their living conditions. They might live in overcrowded, unsafe buildings or temporary structures that can be demolished at any time.
Informal employment also creates problems for governments and the wider economy. These challenges make it harder to develop effective policies and support economic growth.
Since informal workers don't pay income tax or contribute to social security systems, governments lose significant revenue. This reduces funding for public services like healthcare, education and infrastructure.
Informal employment makes it difficult for governments to collect accurate economic data. This affects policy-making and planning for economic development, as officials don't have complete information about employment levels and economic activity.
Nigeria's informal sector employs about 70% of the workforce but contributes little to government revenue. The government estimates it loses billions of naira annually in uncollected taxes. This lack of revenue limits investment in education, healthcare and infrastructure, which could help create more formal jobs. The cycle continues as poor public services make it harder for people to access education and skills training needed for formal employment.
The disadvantages of informal employment create long-term problems that can trap families in poverty for generations. Understanding these cycles is crucial for developing effective solutions.
Informal employment often perpetuates poverty because workers can't save money, invest in education, or build assets. Their children may also end up in informal work, continuing the cycle.
Without access to credit (banks won't lend to people without proof of income), informal workers can't start businesses or invest in better equipment. This limits their ability to increase their earnings or move into formal employment.
While informal employment presents many challenges, governments and organisations are working on solutions to support these workers and help them transition to formal employment.
Some governments are introducing programmes to support informal workers, such as providing basic health insurance, skills training and easier access to business registration. However, these programmes often face funding challenges and limited reach.
Training programmes can help informal workers develop skills needed for formal employment or improve their existing businesses. This might include literacy classes, technical training, or business management skills.
Understanding the disadvantages of informal employment is essential for recognising the challenges faced by millions of workers worldwide. While informal work might provide immediate income, its long-term disadvantages often trap workers and their families in poverty. Addressing these issues requires coordinated efforts from governments, employers and international organisations to create more formal job opportunities and support systems for informal workers.