« Back to Course 🔒 Test Your Knowledge!

Energy Security » Energy Advantages and Disadvantages

What you'll learn this session

Study time: 30 minutes

  • Understand what energy security means and why it matters
  • Compare advantages and disadvantages of renewable energy sources
  • Evaluate the pros and cons of non-renewable energy sources
  • Analyse real-world case studies of energy choices
  • Assess how different energy sources impact the environment and economy

🔒 Unlock Full Course Content

Sign up to access the complete lesson and track your progress!

Unlock This Course

Introduction to Energy Security

Energy security is about having reliable, affordable access to energy when we need it. Think of it like having enough food in your fridge - you want to know it's there when you're hungry! Countries need energy to power homes, factories, transport and everything else that keeps society running.

Key Definitions:

  • Energy Security: Having a reliable, uninterrupted supply of energy at affordable prices.
  • Renewable Energy: Energy from sources that naturally replenish, like wind, solar and water.
  • Non-renewable Energy: Energy from finite sources that will eventually run out, like coal, oil and gas.
  • Energy Mix: The combination of different energy sources a country uses.

Why Energy Security Matters

Without energy security, countries face power cuts, economic problems and social unrest. It's like trying to run a school without electricity - everything stops working!

Renewable Energy Sources

Renewable energy comes from natural sources that won't run out. Let's explore the main types and weigh up their advantages and disadvantages.

Solar Power

Solar panels capture sunlight and convert it into electricity. They're becoming cheaper and more efficient every year.

Advantages

• Free fuel (sunlight)
• No pollution during use
• Low running costs
• Can work on small or large scale

Disadvantages

• Doesn't work at night
• Weather dependent
• High initial costs
• Needs lots of space for large installations

🌎 Environmental Impact

• Zero emissions during operation
• Manufacturing panels creates some pollution
• Panels can be recycled

Wind Power

Wind turbines use moving air to generate electricity. They can be built on land (onshore) or at sea (offshore).

🌀 Advantages

• No fuel costs
• Clean energy production
• Can be built offshore
• Creates jobs in manufacturing and maintenance

Disadvantages

• Wind isn't always blowing
• Can be noisy
• Visual pollution concerns
• Can affect bird migration

🌊 Location Factors

• Need consistent wind speeds
• Coastal areas often ideal
• Must avoid flight paths
• Local community acceptance important

Case Study Focus: Denmark's Wind Success

Denmark generates over 40% of its electricity from wind power. The country invested heavily in wind technology from the 1970s and now exports wind turbines worldwide. However, they still need backup power sources for when the wind doesn't blow, showing that renewable energy works best as part of a mixed energy system.

Hydroelectric Power

Hydroelectric power uses flowing or falling water to turn turbines and generate electricity. It's one of the oldest renewable energy sources.

🌊 Advantages

• Very reliable and predictable
• Can respond quickly to demand changes
• Dams can provide flood control
• Long lifespan (50+ years)
• No direct emissions

Disadvantages

• Expensive to build
• Can flood large areas
• Affects river ecosystems
• May displace communities
• Limited suitable locations

Non-Renewable Energy Sources

Non-renewable energy sources have powered industrial development for centuries, but they come with significant environmental and supply challenges.

Coal Power

Coal is burned to heat water, creating steam that drives turbines. It's been a major energy source since the Industrial Revolution.

Advantages

• Abundant global supplies
• Reliable baseload power
• Existing infrastructure
• Relatively cheap to extract

Disadvantages

• High CO2 emissions
• Air pollution causes health problems
• Mining damages landscapes
• Finite resource

🌍 Environmental Impact

• Major contributor to climate change
• Acid rain from sulfur emissions
• Water pollution from mining
• Habitat destruction

Natural Gas

Natural gas burns cleaner than coal and oil, making it a popular 'transition fuel' as countries move towards renewable energy.

🔥 Advantages

• Lower CO2 emissions than coal
• Quick to start up (good backup power)
• Efficient for heating homes
• Abundant supplies (including fracking)

Disadvantages

• Still produces greenhouse gases
• Price can be volatile
• Fracking raises environmental concerns
• Infrastructure vulnerable to disruption

Case Study Focus: Germany's Energy Transition

Germany is phasing out nuclear power and coal while increasing renewable energy. By 2023, renewables provided over 50% of electricity. However, the country still relies on natural gas imports, highlighting the challenge of energy security during transitions. High energy costs and grid stability issues show that moving to renewables requires careful planning.

Nuclear Power

Nuclear power splits uranium atoms to create heat, which generates electricity. It's controversial but provides large amounts of low-carbon energy.

Advantages

• Very low CO2 emissions
• Reliable baseload power
• Small land footprint
• Fuel lasts a long time

Disadvantages

• Risk of accidents
• Radioactive waste storage
• Very expensive to build
• Long construction times

💰 Economic Factors

• High upfront costs
• Low running costs
• Expensive to decommission
• Requires government support

Comparing Energy Sources

Each energy source has trade-offs between cost, reliability, environmental impact and energy security. Countries must balance these factors when choosing their energy mix.

Energy Security Factors

• Domestic vs imported sources
• Reliability of supply
• Storage capabilities
• Infrastructure resilience
• Political stability of suppliers

🌎 Sustainability Factors

• Greenhouse gas emissions
• Resource depletion
• Waste production
• Ecosystem impacts
• Long-term viability

Case Study Focus: UK Energy Mix Evolution

The UK has dramatically changed its energy mix since 2010. Coal power dropped from 30% to nearly zero, while renewables grew from 7% to over 40% of electricity generation. North Sea oil and gas provided energy security but are declining. The UK now imports more energy, raising security concerns but reducing emissions. Offshore wind has become a major success story, with the UK leading global development.

Future Energy Challenges

As the world transitions to cleaner energy, several challenges must be addressed to maintain energy security while protecting the environment.

🔌 Storage Solutions

Renewable energy is intermittent, so we need better ways to store energy for when the sun doesn't shine or wind doesn't blow. Battery technology is improving rapidly, but large-scale storage remains expensive.

🌐 Grid Modernisation

Electricity grids need upgrading to handle variable renewable energy sources. Smart grids can balance supply and demand automatically, but require significant investment.

Understanding energy advantages and disadvantages helps us make informed decisions about our energy future. The challenge is balancing energy security, environmental protection and economic considerations while meeting growing global energy demand.

🔒 Test Your Knowledge!
Chat to Geography (9-1) tutor