Rural Ecosystems and Human Use » Farming Systems - Arable vs Pastoral

What you'll learn this session

Study time: 30 minutes

Understand the difference between arable and pastoral farming systems
Explore the factors that influence farming choices in rural areas
Examine how physical and human factors affect agricultural decisions
Analyse case studies of different farming systems around the world
Evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of each farming type
Understand how farming systems adapt to environmental challenges

🔒 Unlock Full Course Content

Unlock This Course

Introduction to Farming Systems

Farming is one of the most important human activities that shapes rural landscapes around the world. The type of farming that develops in an area depends on many factors including climate, soil quality, relief and economic conditions. Understanding different farming systems helps us see how humans adapt to and modify their environment to produce food.

Key Definitions:

Arable farming: Growing crops on cultivated land, such as wheat, barley and vegetables.
Pastoral farming: Raising livestock such as cattle, sheep and goats for meat, milk, or wool.
Mixed farming: Combining both crop growing and livestock rearing on the same farm.
Intensive farming: High inputs of labour, capital, or technology per unit area to maximise yields.
Extensive farming: Low inputs per unit area, typically covering large areas of land.

🌾 Arable Farming

Arable farming focuses on growing crops like cereals, vegetables and fruits. It requires fertile soil, adequate rainfall and relatively flat land for machinery. Examples include wheat fields in East Anglia and rice paddies in Asia.

🐄 Pastoral Farming

Pastoral farming involves raising animals for products like meat, milk, eggs and wool. It's often found in areas with poor soil or steep slopes unsuitable for crops. Examples include sheep farming in the Scottish Highlands and cattle ranching in Argentina.

Physical Factors Affecting Farming Systems

The natural environment plays a crucial role in determining what type of farming can succeed in different areas. Farmers must work with the physical conditions of their land rather than against them.

Climate and Weather

Temperature and rainfall patterns are fundamental to farming decisions. Different crops and animals have specific climate requirements that farmers must consider when planning their agricultural activities.

🌡 Temperature

Crops like wheat need warm summers but can tolerate cold winters. Tropical crops like bananas require year-round warmth. Livestock also have temperature preferences - dairy cows produce more milk in cooler conditions.

🌧 Rainfall

Most crops need 500-1000mm of rain annually. Rice requires flooded fields, whilst sheep can graze in areas with just 250mm rainfall. Too much rain can waterlog soil and damage crops.

🌨 Growing Season

The length of frost-free period determines what crops can grow. Northern areas have shorter growing seasons, limiting crop choices. Some areas can grow two or three crops per year.

Soil Quality and Relief

Soil fertility and land shape significantly influence farming choices. Rich, deep soils support intensive arable farming, whilst thin, poor soils are better suited to extensive pastoral farming.

🌱 Soil Characteristics

Fertile soils with good drainage support crops like potatoes and sugar beet. Clay soils retain moisture but can become waterlogged. Sandy soils drain well but may lack nutrients. Chalky soils are often too thin for crops but suitable for sheep grazing.

⛰ Relief and Slope

Flat or gently sloping land allows use of machinery for arable farming. Steep slopes are prone to soil erosion if ploughed, making them better for pastoral farming. Valley floors often have the best soils and are sheltered from wind.

Human Factors Influencing Farming Systems

Economic, social and political factors also shape farming decisions. These human influences can sometimes override physical limitations through technology and investment.

Economic Considerations

Farmers must consider costs, profits and market access when choosing their farming system. Economic factors often determine the intensity and scale of farming operations.

Market Access Example

Dairy farmers near cities can sell fresh milk daily, whilst those in remote areas may focus on cheese production or beef cattle. Transport costs and perishability of products influence these decisions significantly.

💰 Capital Investment

Arable farming often requires expensive machinery like tractors and combine harvesters. Pastoral farming may need less machinery but requires investment in livestock and fencing. Government subsidies can influence these decisions.

👥 Labour Requirements

Intensive arable farming needs seasonal labour for planting and harvesting. Pastoral farming requires year-round care but fewer workers. Family farms often choose systems that match available family labour.

Case Studies of Farming Systems

Case Study: East Anglian Arable Farming

East Anglia in England demonstrates intensive arable farming. The region has flat land, fertile soils and a relatively dry climate perfect for cereals. Large fields allow efficient use of machinery. Farmers grow wheat, barley, sugar beet and potatoes. High technology and fertiliser use maximise yields, but this system requires significant capital investment.

Case Study: Scottish Highland Sheep Farming

The Scottish Highlands show extensive pastoral farming adapted to harsh conditions. Poor soils, steep slopes and cold, wet weather make crop growing difficult. Sheep farming suits this environment as sheep can graze rough pasture and survive harsh winters. This system requires large areas of land but minimal inputs, making it economically viable despite low productivity per hectare.

Comparing Farming Systems

Different farming systems have distinct advantages and challenges that make them suitable for specific environments and economic conditions.

✅ Arable Advantages

Higher yields per hectare, mechanisation possible, crops can be stored, less labour intensive during most of the year, often more profitable per unit area.

❌ Arable Disadvantages

Requires fertile soil and suitable climate, high capital costs for machinery, vulnerable to weather and pests, soil erosion risk, seasonal labour demands.

✅ Pastoral Advantages

Suits marginal land, animals provide multiple products, year-round income possible, lower machinery costs, animals can graze steep slopes safely.

❌ Pastoral Disadvantages

Lower yields per hectare, requires large areas of land, vulnerable to disease, constant labour needed, weather affects animal welfare and productivity.

Modern Adaptations and Challenges

Today's farming systems face new challenges including climate change, environmental concerns and changing consumer demands. Farmers are adapting their systems to meet these challenges whilst maintaining profitability.

Sustainable Farming Practices

Modern farmers increasingly adopt sustainable practices that protect the environment whilst maintaining productivity. These include organic farming, precision agriculture and integrated pest management.

🌱 Organic Methods

Avoiding artificial fertilisers and pesticides, using crop rotation and encouraging biodiversity. This appeals to environmentally conscious consumers but often reduces yields.

💻 Technology Use

GPS-guided tractors, soil sensors and satellite monitoring help farmers use inputs more efficiently. This precision agriculture reduces waste and environmental impact.

🍂 Diversification

Many farms now combine traditional farming with tourism, renewable energy, or food processing to increase income and reduce risk.

Climate Change Impacts

Rising temperatures and changing rainfall patterns are forcing farmers to adapt their systems. Some areas may become suitable for new crops, whilst others face increased drought or flooding. Farmers are selecting more resilient crop varieties and adjusting planting dates to cope with these changes.

🔒 Test Your Knowledge!