☀️ This life
Your actions change the person you become now. Kind choices build a calm, trusting character. Cruel choices bring enemies and regret.
Sign up to access the complete lesson and track your progress!
Unlock This CourseIn Death and the Afterlife: Linear and Cyclical Views, you met the cyclical view of existence. You met the idea that life is more like a wheel than a road. Buddhism is the clearest example of this view.
Buddhists teach that a being does not live once and then finish. After death a being is reborn, then dies, then is reborn again. This continual and endless cycle of birth, death and rebirth is called samsara. Nobody can find a beginning to it, and it does not end by itself. It only ends when a person reaches nibbana, which you will study in Nibbana and the Noble Eightfold Path.
Key terms:
Recall that kamma means intentional action. Buddhists believe that wilful acts of body, speech and mind leave results behind. Skilful acts, such as generosity and kindness, lead to happier results. Unskilful acts, driven by greed, hatred and ignorance, lead to suffering.
The spec says kamma affects the circumstances of this and future existence. So there are two time scales.
Your actions change the person you become now. Kind choices build a calm, trusting character. Cruel choices bring enemies and regret.
Buddhists believe kamma carries on after death. It shapes where a being is reborn and the circumstances it meets there.
This is why rebirth is not random. Kamma is not a prize handed out by a judge. It works like cause and effect, in the way that planting a seed leads to a plant.
Here is a puzzle. Remember from Anicca, Anatta and the Five Khandhas that Buddhists teach anatta: there is no permanent, unchanging self. So what is reborn?
The answer is that nothing solid passes from one life to the next. Instead, a stream of cause and effect carries on. A famous story from the Milindapanha, a Buddhist text, compares it to a flame passed from candle to candle. Light one candle from another. The new flame is not the same as the old one, but it is not completely different either. It exists because of the first flame. In the same way, the next life is not the same person, but it comes from the last one. Kamma and craving keep the flame going.
This also explains why Buddhists prefer the word rebirth to reincarnation. Reincarnation suggests that a soul moves into a new body. Buddhists teach no such soul.
Buddhists teach that a being can be reborn in more than one kind of existence. Traditional teaching names six realms:
Every realm is impermanent. Even a being reborn as a god will die when the good kamma that caused it runs out. Many Buddhists see the human realm as the best place to follow the Buddha's path, because humans feel both pleasure and pain, and can choose to change.
Not all Buddhists take the realms literally. Some see them as states of mind that people pass through in a single day: calm and happy, jealous, greedy, angry.
Buddhists trust the Buddha. Tradition says that on the night of his enlightenment he saw his own past lives, and he taught rebirth ever after. The Jataka tales tell of his many earlier lives.
People are born into very different lives. Rebirth and kamma give a reason, without a God who chooses. It also means actions have results, even when good people suffer in this life.
Some Buddhists point to people, especially young children, who seem to remember earlier lives. Tibetan Buddhists search for children they believe are the rebirth of a respected teacher.
Do not write that Buddhists believe in a soul that moves from body to body. Say that a stream of kamma and craving carries on, like a flame passed from candle to candle. Also, do not say that being reborn as a god is the goal. Even gods remain in samsara.
Paper 1 style. Parts (a) and (b) test AO1. Parts (c) and (d) test AO1 and AO2.
(a) Identify three beliefs about what happens after death. [3 marks]
(b) Choose one religion. Outline two teachings about rebirth in this religion. [4 marks]
(c) Choose one religion. Explain why followers of this religion believe in rebirth. [6 marks]
(d) 'Rebirth is the best explanation for why people are born into such different lives.' Evaluate this statement, showing you have considered different points of view. In your answer you should refer to at least one religion. [12 marks]
(a) 1. Rebirth (1). 2. Resurrection (1). 3. Nothing happens, because consciousness ends at death (1).
(b) Buddhists teach that beings are caught in samsara, the endless cycle of birth, death and rebirth (1), which only ends when a person reaches nibbana (1). Buddhists also teach that kamma, wilful acts, affects the circumstances of future existence (1), so skilful acts lead to happier results and unskilful acts lead to suffering (1).
(c) Buddhists believe in rebirth first because the Buddha taught it. Tradition says that on the night of his enlightenment he saw his own past lives, and the Jataka tales tell of his earlier lives, so followers trust his words.
A second reason is that rebirth explains fairness. People are born into very different lives. Buddhists believe kamma from earlier lives helps to shape these circumstances, without a God who chooses, so actions always have results.
A third reason is the accounts of past lives. Some Buddhists point to young children who seem to remember earlier lives, and Tibetan Buddhists search for children believed to be the rebirth of a respected teacher. This means rebirth is not just a theory but part of the way they understand life and death.
(d) Plan. For: Buddhists say kamma from earlier lives helps to explain why one person is born healthy and loved and another is not; no God is needed, so a loving God is not blamed for unfairness; it fits the cyclical view that every action has a result.
Against: there is no scientific evidence for rebirth, and accounts of past lives can be explained in other ways; non-religious people say differences come from genes, family and chance; Christians and Muslims say God, not kamma, is behind life; some modern Buddhists read rebirth as moment-to-moment change, not a link between lives; the explanation could also seem to blame those who suffer.
Possible conclusion: judge each point as you go, then pick a side. For example: I partly disagree. Rebirth gives Buddhists a fair and consistent reason, but 'best' is too strong because it cannot be tested, and genes and upbringing explain much of the difference in a way anyone can check.
In part (d), look at the word 'best'. A strong answer compares rebirth with other explanations, such as God's plan, genes and chance, and says why one works better than the others.