What is social stratification? » Marxism - ideological control

What you'll learn this session

Study time: 30 minutes

The concept of social stratification and its importance in sociology
Karl Marx's theory of class and capitalism
How ideological control works according to Marxist theory
The role of key institutions in maintaining ideological control
Real-world examples and case studies of ideological control
Contemporary applications of Marxist ideas about ideological control

Understanding Social Stratification

Social stratification refers to the way society is organised in layers or strata, with some groups having more power, wealth and status than others. It's like a layer cake, with different groups stacked on top of each other based on their position in society.

Key Definitions:

Social Stratification: The division of society into hierarchical layers based on wealth, power and status.
Class: A group of people who share a similar economic position in society.
Ideology: A system of ideas and beliefs that shapes how people understand the world.

★ Marx's View of Society

Karl Marx (1818-1883) believed that society is divided primarily by economic factors. He saw society as split between two main classes:

Bourgeoisie: The ruling class who own the means of production (factories, land, resources)
Proletariat: The working class who sell their labour to survive

According to Marx, these classes have opposing interests, which creates conflict and tension in society.

★ What is Capitalism?

Capitalism is an economic system where:

Private individuals and businesses own the means of production
People work for wages
Goods and services are produced for profit
There is competition between businesses

Marx argued that capitalism naturally creates inequality and exploitation.

Marxism and Ideological Control

A key question for Marx was: Why don't the working class revolt against their exploitation? His answer was ideological control - the ways the ruling class gets the working class to accept their position in society.

What is Ideological Control?

Ideological control refers to how the ruling class shapes the ideas, beliefs and values of society to maintain their power. Marx argued that "the ideas of the ruling class are in every epoch the ruling ideas" - meaning that the bourgeoisie control not just the economy but also how people think.

Key Concept: False Consciousness

False consciousness is when the working class misunderstands their true position in society. They accept ideas that go against their own interests because they've been influenced by ruling class ideology. For example, a factory worker might believe they can become rich through hard work, even though the system is stacked against them.

How Ideological Control Works

Marx and later Marxist thinkers identified several ways that ideological control operates in society:

♦ Education

Schools teach values that support capitalism:

Competition between students
Respect for authority
Preparing students for work
Teaching that success comes from individual effort

♦ Media

Media outlets often:

Are owned by wealthy corporations
Promote consumerism through advertising
Distract from serious issues with entertainment
Present capitalism as natural and inevitable

♦ Religion

Marx called religion "the opium of the people" because:

It encourages acceptance of suffering
Promises rewards in the afterlife
Promotes obedience and respect for authority
Discourages challenging the status quo

Gramsci's Concept of Hegemony

Antonio Gramsci (1891-1937) developed Marx's ideas about ideological control with his concept of hegemony. This refers to how the ruling class maintains power not just through force, but by winning the consent of the people they rule over.

Hegemony works when:

The working class accepts ruling class ideas as "common sense"
Alternative ways of organising society seem impossible or unrealistic
People consent to their own exploitation because they believe the system is fair

Case Study: Advertising and Ideological Control

Modern advertising doesn't just sell products - it sells a way of life. Consider how adverts work:

They suggest happiness comes from buying things
They create artificial "needs" for new products
They promote individualism over community
They associate success with consumption and wealth

From a Marxist perspective, advertising is a powerful form of ideological control that keeps people focused on consumption rather than questioning the economic system.

The Role of Key Institutions

Louis Althusser (1918-1990) developed Marx's ideas by identifying two types of institutions that maintain ideological control:

♥ Repressive State Apparatuses (RSAs)

These maintain control through force or the threat of force:

Police
Courts
Prisons
Military

They step in when ideological control fails and people challenge the system.

♥ Ideological State Apparatuses (ISAs)

These maintain control through ideas and beliefs:

Education system
Religious institutions
Family
Media
Legal system
Political system

These institutions help spread ruling class ideas throughout society.

Contemporary Examples of Ideological Control

Marxist ideas about ideological control can help us understand many aspects of modern society:

Social Media and Ideological Control

Social media platforms might seem to give everyone a voice, but from a Marxist perspective, they can be seen as new tools for ideological control:

They're owned by some of the world's wealthiest corporations
They collect data to target advertising more effectively
They promote consumerism and celebrity culture
They can create "echo chambers" that limit exposure to alternative ideas
They often distract from serious political and economic issues

Case Study: The 2008 Financial Crisis

The 2008 global financial crisis provides an interesting case study for Marxist analysis of ideological control:

Despite being caused by risky banking practices, much of the blame was shifted to government spending
The solution was presented as "austerity" - cutting public services rather than regulating banks
The media often focused on "benefit scroungers" rather than tax avoidance by the wealthy
The idea that "there is no alternative" to capitalism was reinforced despite its obvious failures

Marxists would argue this shows how ideological control works to protect the interests of the wealthy even during times of crisis.

Criticisms of Marxist Views on Ideological Control

While Marxist ideas about ideological control are influential, they have been criticised for several reasons:

Too deterministic: They can make it seem like people have no free will or ability to think for themselves
Oversimplified: Modern societies have complex class structures, not just two opposing classes
Outdated: Some argue that in the age of the internet, controlling information is harder than ever
Ignores other factors: Focuses too much on class and not enough on gender, ethnicity, or other forms of inequality

Summary: Key Points About Marxism and Ideological Control

Marx believed society is divided into classes based on economic position
The ruling class maintains power partly through controlling ideas and beliefs
This ideological control happens through institutions like education, media and religion
False consciousness prevents the working class from recognising their exploitation
Gramsci's concept of hegemony explains how consent is manufactured
Althusser identified different types of institutions that maintain control
These ideas can help us understand aspects of contemporary society

Remember: Whether or not you agree with Marx's analysis, his ideas provide useful tools for thinking critically about how power works in society and whose interests are served by the dominant ideas of our time.

🧠 Test Your Knowledge!