The aim of the practical
In this required practical you investigate the effect of light or gravity on the growth of newly germinated seedlings. You already know that shoots and roots respond to these stimuli. Now you collect your own evidence.
You record your results in two ways. First, as length measurements. Second, as accurate, labelled biological drawings that show the effects. Both are needed, because a number tells you how much growth happened and a drawing shows you which way the seedling grew.
Key terms:
- Germinate: when a seed starts to grow into a new plant.
- Seedling: a very young plant that has just germinated.
- Biological drawing: a clear, accurate, labelled drawing of what you can see.
Setting up the investigation
Use seedlings that have only just germinated, such as cress or mustard seedlings. They grow quickly, so you can see changes within a few days. Choose one stimulus to test. The two set-ups below are the usual choices.
☀ Testing light
Put seedlings in a box with a hole or slit cut in one side, so light reaches them from one direction only (one-sided light). Put a second set of seedlings in the same conditions but with light from above or all round, as a comparison.
🌱 Testing gravity
Fix seedlings to damp paper or cotton wool in a dish, for example with tape, so they cannot slip. Turn the dish on its side, so the roots and shoots lie sideways. Keep the dish in the dark, so light cannot affect the result. A second dish stays upright as a comparison.
Choosing only one stimulus matters. If you test gravity, light must not come from one side, or you will not know which stimulus caused the bend.
Method
- Label your dishes, pots or boxes with a pencil or marker so you know which is which.
- Make sure each pot has the same amount of damp compost or damp paper, and the same number of seedlings.
- Measure the length of each shoot (and each root, in a gravity test) with a ruler in millimetres. Record these as the starting lengths.
- Make a labelled drawing of one or more seedlings at the start.
- Set up the light or gravity condition, and leave a comparison group in normal conditions.
- Leave the seedlings for the same length of time, for example 3 or 4 days. Keep them damp, using the same amount of water each day.
- Measure every shoot (and root) again and make a second drawing of the same seedlings. Note the direction of growth in your drawings.
- Repeat the investigation, or use plenty of seedlings, so you can calculate a mean.
A bent shoot is hard to measure with a straight ruler. Lay a piece of thread along the shoot, then straighten the thread and measure it.
Variables
🔧 Independent
The thing you change: the direction of the light, or the position of the seedlings (upright or on their side).
📏 Dependent
The thing you measure: the length of the shoots or roots, and the direction of growth.
⚖ Control
Keep the same: type and age of seedling, temperature, water, compost and time.
Recording results
Length measurements
Put your results in a table with a title and units in the column headings. Work out the growth of each seedling, then the mean.
Worked example
Five seedlings in one-sided light were all 12 mm long at the start. After 4 days they measured 30, 28, 33, 29 and 30 mm. Total length: 30 + 28 + 33 + 29 + 30 = 150 mm. Mean length = 150 / 5 = 30 mm. Mean growth = 30 - 12 = 18 mm.
Labelled biological drawings
Drawings show effects that numbers cannot, such as a shoot bending or a root turning. A good drawing:
- is drawn in sharp pencil, with clear single lines and no shading or colouring
- is large, using at least half the space, with the correct proportions
- has a title and shows the stimulus, such as the direction of the light
- has straight label lines that touch the part being labelled and do not cross
- is labelled with words such as shoot, root, leaf and seed
Drawing the seedling before and after lets you compare them. For example, you can show that a shoot grew upright at the start and curved towards the light by the end.
Safety and ethics
- Wash your hands after handling compost, seedlings or damp paper.
- Take care with scissors or a craft knife if you cut the hole in a box, and cut away from your body.
- Use plants safely and ethically. Do not waste seedlings, and dispose of them properly at the end.
- Do not eat the seedlings, and clean the bench when you finish.
Errors and improvements
Examiners often ask you to suggest improvements. Common problems are:
- Seedlings differ in size. Use more seedlings and calculate a mean.
- Curved shoots are hard to measure. Use thread, or measure from photographs.
- Light leaks into the box or a window lets in extra light. Use a thick card box and keep it away from other light sources.
- Different temperatures or water. Keep the pots together and water them equally.
- Short time. A longer investigation may give clearer results.
A further investigation could change one thing, such as the colour of the light or the position of the slit.
Common mistakes
Students draw a shoot with no title or labels, or shade it in. They also forget to keep the dish in the dark during a gravity test, so light affects the result as well. Many forget units, and some change two things at once, which makes the results unfair.
Exam-style question
A student investigated the effect of one-sided light on cress seedlings. They put seedlings in a box with a slit in one side and measured the shoot length at the start and after 4 days. They also made a drawing of the seedlings at the end.
(a) Name the independent variable. [1 mark]
(b) Give two variables the student should control. [2 marks]
(c) Give one improvement to make the mean growth more reliable. [1 mark]
(d) Describe two features of a good biological drawing. [2 marks]
Model answer
(a) The direction of the light, or light from one side only. (1)
(b) Any two from: type or age of seedlings, temperature, amount of water, type of compost, time left. (1) (1)
(c) Use more seedlings, or repeat the investigation, then calculate a mean. (1)
(d) Any two from: sharp pencil lines, no shading, large and in proportion, title, straight label lines, labels on parts. (1) (1)
Exam tip
When asked for a control variable, name something specific such as "same temperature". Never write just "keep it fair".