Conservation and Tourism: Finding the Balance
Tourism can have both positive and negative impacts on natural and built environments. Understanding how to manage these impacts through conservation and regeneration is crucial for sustainable tourism development.
Key Definitions:
- Conservation: The protection, preservation, management, or restoration of natural environments and the ecological communities that inhabit them.
- Regeneration: The revival of economic, social and environmental strength in areas that have experienced decline.
- Sustainable Tourism: Tourism that takes full account of its current and future economic, social and environmental impacts.
🏠 Environmental Conservation
Tourism can help protect natural environments by providing economic value to conservation. When tourists pay to visit protected areas, this money can fund conservation efforts. However, without proper management, tourism can damage the very environments people come to see.
🏙 Heritage Conservation
Historic buildings, monuments and cultural sites attract tourists. Tourism revenue can help preserve these sites, but excessive visitor numbers can cause wear and tear. Finding the right balance is key to sustainable heritage tourism.
Conservation Approaches in Tourism
Different strategies are used to protect environments while allowing tourism to flourish:
🛡 Protected Areas
National parks, nature reserves and marine protected areas limit development and control visitor numbers to protect ecosystems.
📖 Education
Visitor centres, guided tours and interpretation boards help tourists understand the importance of conservation and how to minimise their impact.
💰 Economic Tools
Entry fees, permits and tourist taxes can generate funds for conservation and limit visitor numbers to sustainable levels.
Case Study Focus: Galápagos Islands, Ecuador
The Galápagos Islands face the challenge of balancing tourism with conservation of their unique ecosystems. Measures include:
- Strict visitor quotas and guided tours only
- $100 national park entry fee that funds conservation
- Designated visitor sites to limit environmental impact
- Regulations requiring tourists to stay on marked trails
Despite these measures, increasing tourist numbers (from 40,000 in 1990 to over 275,000 in 2019) continue to put pressure on the islands' fragile ecosystems.
Regeneration Through Tourism
Tourism can breathe new life into declining areas, creating jobs and improving infrastructure. This regeneration can happen in both urban and rural settings.
🌃 Urban Regeneration
Former industrial cities have transformed waterfronts, factories and warehouses into attractions, hotels and entertainment venues. This brings visitors, creates jobs and improves the urban environment.
🌲 Rural Regeneration
Tourism can help rural areas facing agricultural decline by providing alternative income sources. Farm diversification into accommodation, farm shops and activities helps keep rural communities viable.
Case Study Focus: Liverpool Waterfront, UK
Liverpool's historic docklands declined severely after the 1970s with the loss of shipping trade. Tourism-led regeneration has transformed the area:
- Albert Dock renovation created museums, galleries, shops and restaurants
- UNESCO World Heritage status (2004-2021) recognised the city's maritime history
- Liverpool ONE shopping development improved retail offering
- New hotels, cruise terminal and conference facilities
- Cultural events like the European Capital of Culture (2008) boosted visitor numbers
Results: 54 million visitors annually, supporting 49,000 jobs and contributing ÂŁ4.3 billion to the local economy.
Challenges and Conflicts
Conservation and regeneration through tourism isn't always straightforward. Several challenges can arise:
🔬 Overtourism
Too many visitors can damage environments and heritage sites and reduce quality of life for local residents.
💵 Economic Pressures
Short-term economic gains may be prioritised over long-term conservation needs, especially in less developed regions.
👪 Local Conflicts
Tensions can arise between conservation goals, tourism development and local community needs.
Sustainable Approaches
Successful conservation and regeneration through tourism requires careful planning and management:
Key Strategies for Sustainable Tourism Development
These approaches help balance tourism growth with conservation needs:
- Carrying Capacity Assessment: Determining how many visitors an area can sustainably support.
- Community Involvement: Ensuring local people participate in and benefit from tourism development.
- Visitor Management: Using techniques like timed tickets, visitor dispersal and seasonal pricing.
- Certification Schemes: Eco-labels and sustainable tourism certifications that encourage best practices.
- Adaptive Management: Monitoring impacts and adjusting management approaches as needed.
Case Study Focus: Maya Bay, Thailand
Made famous by the film "The Beach," Maya Bay on Phi Phi Leh Island received up to 5,000 visitors daily, causing severe damage to coral reefs and the beach environment.
Conservation action: Thai authorities closed the bay to tourists in 2018 to allow environmental recovery. When it reopened in 2022, strict new rules were implemented:
- Visitor numbers limited to 375 people at a time
- No swimming allowed to protect recovering coral
- Boats cannot enter the bay; visitors use a pier at the back of the island
- Time-limited visits of one hour
Results: Coral has begun to recover and blacktip reef sharks have returned to the bay, while tourism continues in a more sustainable form.
Evaluating Conservation and Regeneration Success
How do we know if conservation and regeneration efforts are working? Several indicators can be used:
🌱 Environmental Indicators
- Biodiversity levels
- Water and air quality
- Habitat condition
- Wildlife population numbers
🏢 Socio-economic Indicators
- Employment rates
- Business start-ups
- Property values
- Community satisfaction
- Cultural heritage preservation
Key Revision Points
When studying conservation and regeneration in tourism, remember:
- Tourism can both help and harm conservation efforts – management is key
- Regeneration through tourism can revitalise declining urban and rural areas
- Successful case studies show the importance of balancing visitor numbers with environmental protection
- Local communities should be involved in and benefit from tourism development
- Sustainable approaches require ongoing monitoring and adaptation
For your exam, be prepared to discuss specific examples of conservation and regeneration projects, evaluating their success and challenges. Remember to consider different stakeholder perspectives and both positive and negative impacts.