Factors Affecting Tourism Development and Management » Carrying Capacity and Overtourism

What you'll learn this session

Study time: 30 minutes

Define carrying capacity and its different types
Understand the concept of overtourism and its impacts
Explore strategies for managing tourism numbers
Examine real-world case studies of overtourism
Learn how destinations can achieve sustainable tourism development

🔒 Unlock Full Course Content

Unlock This Course

Understanding Carrying Capacity in Tourism

Every tourist destination has limits to how many visitors it can handle before negative impacts start to occur. This concept is known as 'carrying capacity' and it's crucial for sustainable tourism management.

Key Definitions:

Carrying Capacity: The maximum number of people who can visit a destination without causing unacceptable damage to the physical environment, economic conditions, or social fabric of the host community.
Overtourism: When too many tourists visit a destination, causing the quality of life for residents to deteriorate and the visitor experience to worsen.

♦ Physical Carrying Capacity

The maximum number of visitors a site can physically accommodate. This relates to space and infrastructure limitations (e.g., number of hotel rooms, parking spaces, or physical space at attractions).

♦ Environmental Carrying Capacity

The point beyond which tourism activities cause environmental damage to natural habitats, wildlife, or ecosystems (e.g., coral reef damage from too many snorkellers).

♦ Social Carrying Capacity

The level beyond which the local community experiences unacceptable changes to their way of life or where tourists' experiences are negatively affected by overcrowding.

♦ Economic Carrying Capacity

The point where tourism growth begins to have negative economic impacts (e.g., rising property prices forcing locals out, or tourism jobs replacing traditional industries).

The Growing Problem of Overtourism

In recent years, many popular destinations have experienced 'overtourism' - when visitor numbers exceed carrying capacity, causing problems for both locals and tourists. Global tourism has grown dramatically, with international arrivals increasing from 25 million in 1950 to over 1.4 billion in 2019 (pre-COVID).

Why Has Overtourism Become Such a Problem?

Rising global wealth: More people can afford to travel
Low-cost airlines: Making travel more accessible
Social media: Creating 'must-visit' destinations through Instagram and other platforms
Cruise ships: Bringing thousands of visitors to destinations simultaneously
Home-sharing platforms: Like Airbnb, increasing accommodation in residential areas

Impacts of Exceeding Carrying Capacity

! Environmental Impacts

Pollution (air, water, noise)
Damage to natural sites
Wildlife disturbance
Increased waste
Resource depletion

! Social Impacts

Local housing shortages
Congestion in public spaces
Loss of cultural authenticity
Tension between locals and tourists
Pressure on local services

! Economic Impacts

Rising property prices
Local businesses replaced by tourist shops
Seasonal unemployment
Economic dependency on tourism
Inflation affecting locals

Strategies for Managing Tourism Numbers

Destinations are increasingly implementing strategies to manage visitor numbers and prevent overtourism. These approaches aim to balance economic benefits with environmental and social sustainability.

✓ Visitor Management Techniques

Ticketing and pre-booking: Limiting daily visitor numbers
Price mechanisms: Higher fees during peak times
Time-based strategies: Extended opening hours to spread visitors
Visitor education: Teaching responsible tourism behaviour
Technology: Apps showing real-time congestion levels

✓ Destination Management Approaches

Marketing less-visited areas: Promoting alternative attractions
Seasonal adjustments: Promoting off-season visits
Tourist taxes: Generating funds for management
Regulations: Limiting cruise ships or tour buses
Community involvement: Including locals in decision-making

Case Study: Venice, Italy

Venice receives around 30 million visitors annually despite having only 55,000 residents. The city has implemented several measures to manage overtourism:

Introducing an entrance fee for day visitors (up to €10 during peak times)
Installing turnstiles to control access to busy areas
Banning large cruise ships from sailing through the historic centre
Using CCTV and mobile phone data to monitor crowd levels
Promoting visits to lesser-known islands in the Venetian lagoon

Despite these efforts, Venice continues to struggle with balancing tourism income with quality of life for residents and preservation of its historic environment.

Measuring and Monitoring Carrying Capacity

For effective management, destinations need to measure and monitor their carrying capacity. This isn't just about counting visitors - it requires a holistic approach.

Key Indicators for Monitoring Carrying Capacity

Environmental indicators: Water quality, waste levels, wildlife population changes
Social indicators: Resident satisfaction surveys, ratio of tourists to locals, crime rates
Economic indicators: Housing affordability, business diversity, tourism income distribution
Infrastructure indicators: Traffic congestion, water usage, energy consumption
Visitor experience: Satisfaction surveys, complaints, return visit intentions

Case Study: Maya Bay, Thailand

Made famous by the film "The Beach," Maya Bay on Phi Phi Leh Island received up to 5,000 visitors daily, causing severe damage to its coral reef ecosystem. In 2018, authorities closed the bay completely to allow recovery. When it reopened in 2022, strict measures were implemented:

Visitor numbers limited to 375 people at any one time
No swimming allowed in the bay to protect recovering coral
Boats must dock at a designated platform rather than on the beach
Advance booking required with a maximum stay of one hour

This case demonstrates how exceeding environmental carrying capacity required drastic action, but also how proper management can allow tourism to continue sustainably.

Achieving Sustainable Tourism Development

The ultimate goal is to develop tourism that stays within carrying capacity limits while still providing economic benefits. This requires long-term planning and collaboration between all stakeholders.

♥ Sustainable Tourism Principles

Balance: Meeting the needs of visitors, the industry, the environment and host communities
Long-term planning: Considering future generations, not just short-term gains
Inclusivity: Ensuring benefits are shared across the community
Adaptability: Monitoring impacts and adjusting strategies as needed
Education: Raising awareness among tourists and tourism businesses

♥ Stakeholder Collaboration

Effective management of carrying capacity requires cooperation between:

Local government and planning authorities
Tourism businesses and industry associations
Local residents and community groups
Environmental organisations
Tourists themselves

Conclusion: The Future of Tourism Management

As global tourism continues to grow, understanding and respecting carrying capacity will become increasingly important. The COVID-19 pandemic provided many destinations with an opportunity to rethink their approach to tourism development and management.

Future trends are likely to include:

Greater use of technology to monitor and manage visitor flows
More emphasis on quality over quantity of tourists
Development of alternative destinations to reduce pressure on hotspots
Increased community involvement in tourism planning
Growing consumer demand for more sustainable and responsible tourism experiences

By understanding carrying capacity and implementing effective management strategies, destinations can avoid the problems of overtourism while still enjoying the benefits that tourism can bring.

🔒 Test Your Knowledge!