🚢 From the ports...
Within days, sailors and workers in ports and cities such as Hamburg and Bremen copied Kiel. Councils of workers and soldiers took over town after town. Soldiers sent to stop them often joined in.
'Germany: Development of Dictatorship, 1918-45' is one of the eight Paper 1 depth studies. You study two of them, so only work through these lessons if Germany is one of your chosen options.
Sign up to access the complete lesson and track your progress!
Unlock This CourseIn 1918 Germany was an empire ruled by Kaiser Wilhelm II. It had a parliament, the Reichstag, but real power lay with the Kaiser. He chose the chancellor (the head of the government) and he commanded the army. Germany had been fighting the First World War since 1914, and by autumn 1918 it was losing.
Key terms:
The revolution started in the navy. At the end of October 1918, naval commanders ordered the fleet out for one last battle against the British. The sailors knew the war was lost and saw no reason to die for their officers' honour. Crews at the port of Wilhelmshaven refused to obey.
On 3 November the mutiny spread to the great naval base at Kiel. Sailors there protested to free their arrested comrades, and shots were fired. By 4 November the sailors, joined by local workers, controlled the town. They set up a workers' and soldiers' council to run it.
Within days, sailors and workers in ports and cities such as Hamburg and Bremen copied Kiel. Councils of workers and soldiers took over town after town. Soldiers sent to stop them often joined in.
On 7 November in Munich, the socialist Kurt Eisner declared the state of Bavaria a republic and its king fled. Unrest spread fast because people were hungry, the war was lost and nobody wanted to defend the old system.
On 9 November the revolution reached Berlin. Workers went on strike and huge crowds marched into the city centre. Soldiers in the city refused to stop them.
On 10 November Wilhelm II crossed the border into exile in the Netherlands, where he lived for the rest of his life.
No single event forced him out. Defeat in the war destroyed his authority. The mutinies and strikes showed he had lost control of the country. Wilson's demands made him an obstacle to peace. The final blow was losing the support of the army.
The new government's first task was to end the war. On 11 November a German group led by the politician Matthias Erzberger signed the armistice in a railway carriage in the forest of Compiègne in France. The fighting stopped at 11 o'clock that morning.
The terms were harsh. Germany had to pull its troops out of France and Belgium, hand over large numbers of weapons including its submarines, and let Allied troops occupy German land west of the River Rhine. The blockade would carry on until a peace treaty was signed.
The timing mattered. The German group was led by a civilian politician, not by the Kaiser or the army's top commanders, and it signed two days after the republic was declared. From its very first days the republic was linked to defeat, even though the war had been lost before it existed.
On 10 November Ebert set up a temporary government called the Council of People's Representatives. It had six members: three from the SPD and three from a more left-wing party that had broken away from it.
The government promised freedom of speech and the vote for all adults, including women for the first time. An eight-hour working day was agreed. Elections were promised so that the German people could choose a National Assembly to write a constitution.
Ebert feared chaos and a communist revolution like Russia's. On 10 November he made a deal by telephone with General Groener: the army would support the government, and the government would keep order and oppose communism. The Kaiser's officers, judges and civil servants stayed in their jobs.
This is why historians call the German Revolution a limited one. The Kaiser had gone and Germany was becoming a democracy, but the army and the old officials kept their power. The far left felt betrayed, and that anger led to the events in the lesson Threats From Left and Right: Spartacists and the Kapp Putsch.
The elections were held on 19 January 1919. The SPD won the most votes, and parties that supported democracy won a large majority. Because Berlin was still unsafe, the National Assembly met in the quiet town of Weimar in February 1919 and chose Ebert as the republic's first president. This is why the new state is known as the Weimar Republic.
The armistice was not the peace treaty. It only stopped the fighting. The Kaiser did not step down in Berlin. His abdication was announced for him while he was in Belgium. And it was not a communist revolution. Ebert and the SPD worked with the army to stop the far left.
Extract A (a practice extract written for this lesson, in the style of a modern history book)
From a modern history textbook.
By 9 November 1918 Wilhelm II was a ruler in name only. Hidden away at army headquarters in Spa, he clung to the fantasy of leading his troops home to crush the revolution. His own generals bluntly told him that the army would no longer follow him. In Berlin, his chancellor did not even wait for his agreement before announcing that he had gone. The next morning the abandoned Kaiser slipped quietly across the Dutch border, deserted by those who had once obeyed him.
(a) What impression does the author give about the abdication of the Kaiser?
You must use Extract A to explain your answer. [6 marks]
The author gives the impression that the Kaiser's abdication was forced on a powerless man whom everyone had abandoned. The language makes him seem weak and out of touch: he was a ruler 'in name only' who 'clung to the fantasy' of crushing the revolution, which suggests he could not see how hopeless his position was. Words such as 'abandoned' and 'deserted' stress that he had lost all support, and 'slipped quietly' makes his exit sound small and shameful. The author also selects only moments where others act against him: the generals 'bluntly' reject him and the chancellor 'did not even wait' for his agreement. Nothing is said about any loyalty to him or any choice he made, so the abdication appears as something done to him.
What lifts this to the top level: it names one clear impression, then explains how the author's choice of words and choice of what to include and leave out create it.
Don't retell what happened to the Kaiser. Quote two or three loaded words, such as 'fantasy' or 'deserted', and say what each one makes the reader think. Then add one sentence on what the author chose to leave out.