Radioactivity ยป Practical: Penetration of Radiation

What you'll learn this session

Study time: 30 minutes

Edexcel spec: 7.6

  • How to set up the penetration investigation with a source, a Geiger-Müller tube and a counter
  • How to test paper, aluminium, lead and air, and correct every reading for background
  • How to read a results table and name an unknown source
  • How to stay safe, and what a demonstration or simulation shows

๐Ÿ”’ Unlock Full Course Content

Sign up to access the complete lesson and track your progress!

Unlock This Course

The idea of the practical

Remember, alpha, beta and gamma are stopped by different materials. In Alpha, Beta and Gamma Radiation you learnt that fact. In this required practical you find out how to test it and how to show it with numbers.

The spec says you can do this with real radioactive sources or with simulations. Real sources are sealed, weak and handled only by a trained adult, so most students see a teacher demonstration or use a computer simulation. You can still answer every exam question by knowing the method, the results and the safety rules below.

Key terms:

  • Sealed source: a radioactive source locked inside a metal case, so the radioactive material cannot escape or touch anyone.
  • Absorber: any material placed between the source and the detector to stop some of the radiation.

The apparatus

Draw it as a straight line, from left to right:

  • a sealed source (alpha, beta or gamma) held in a clamp or with tongs, with its opening pointing at the tube and away from people;
  • a gap, where the absorbers go (paper, aluminium sheets, lead sheets);
  • a Geiger-Müller tube, lined up with the source and fixed at the same distance every time;
  • a counter connected to the tube, which shows the number of counts, or counts per minute (see Detecting Radiation and Background Radiation).

The method

  1. With no source in the room (or the source far away in its box), switch on the counter and measure the background count for 1 minute. Repeat twice more and find the mean.
  2. Set up the source, the gap and the tube in a straight line, a few centimetres apart.
  3. Measure the count for 1 minute with nothing in the gap.
  4. Place a sheet of paper in the gap. Measure the count for 1 minute.
  5. Replace the paper with aluminium sheets, increasing the thickness (for example 1 mm, 2 mm, 3 mm and so on). Measure 1 minute each time.
  6. Replace the aluminium with lead sheets, again increasing the thickness, and measure 1 minute each time.
  7. Take the absorbers away. Move the tube further away in air in steps, for example 2 cm, 4 cm, 6 cm, 10 cm, 30 cm, 100 cm, and measure 1 minute at each distance.
  8. For every reading, work out the corrected count rate: count rate − mean background count rate.
  9. Repeat the whole test for each source.

🔄 Independent

The absorber (paper, aluminium, lead) and its thickness, or the distance in air.

📊 Dependent

The corrected count rate in counts per minute.

🔧 Control

The same source, the same tube, the same source-to-tube distance (when testing absorbers) and the same counting time.

Results: three unknown sources

A class measures a background of 24 counts per minute. They test three sources, X, Y and Z, each with the tube at the same distance. Each source has a row of measured counts and a row of corrected counts.

SourceNo absorberPaper3 mm aluminiumThick lead
X (measured)504272524
X (corrected)480310
Y (measured)3243183626
Y (corrected)300294122
Z (measured)17417216054
Z (corrected)15014813630

Each corrected value is the measured value minus 24. For source X with no absorber, 504 − 24 = 480 counts per minute.

🔵 X is alpha

Paper cuts the corrected rate from 480 to 3, which is almost nothing. Only alpha is stopped by paper.

🟠 Y is beta

Paper hardly changes the rate (300 to 294). A few mm of aluminium stops almost all of it (12). Beta passes paper but is stopped by aluminium.

⚡ Z is gamma

Paper and aluminium barely change the rate (150, 148, 136). Even thick lead leaves 30. Gamma is the most penetrating and is only reduced, never fully stopped.

Distance in air

Air is also an absorber. For a beta source the count falls over a distance of about a metre. For an alpha source it falls to background within only a few centimetres, as these example values show.

Distance from source (cm)24610
Corrected count rate (counts per min)40019020

Alpha has a very short range. Gamma rays fall off only gradually with distance, and they can travel many metres in air.

Conclusions

  • Alpha: stopped by paper, and by a few centimetres of air.
  • Beta: passes paper, stopped by a few millimetres of aluminium, and travels about a metre in air.
  • Gamma: passes paper and aluminium, and is reduced by thick lead but never completely stopped.

Worked example

Question: The background is 20 counts per minute. A source gives 220 counts per minute with nothing in the gap and 218 with paper. With 4 mm of aluminium it gives 24. Identify the source. [3 marks]

Step 1: Correct each reading. 220 − 20 = 200, 218 − 20 = 198, 24 − 20 = 4.

Step 2: Paper makes almost no difference, so it is not alpha.

Step 3: Aluminium cuts the rate from 198 to 4, so the radiation is stopped by a few mm of aluminium. The source is beta.

Safety

  • Only a trained adult handles the source. Students watch a demonstration or use a simulation.
  • Use tongs to pick up the source and never touch it.
  • Point the source away from people, and never look at the open end.
  • Keep the exposure to the shortest possible time.
  • Store the source in a lead-lined box straight after use.

Common mistakes

  • Forgetting to subtract the background from every reading. Then the lead reading looks like radiation getting through, when it is background.
  • Saying a reading of 24 means the radiation was stopped to zero. Only the corrected count of 0 means that.
  • Saying lead stops gamma completely. It only reduces it.
  • Changing the source-to-tube distance when comparing absorbers. That makes it an unfair test.
  • Saying "human error" to explain a difference. Counts are random, so say that readings vary and a mean of repeats is better.

Exam-style question

A teacher measures the background count as 18 counts per minute. A sealed source Q is then tested with a Geiger-Müller tube. With nothing in the gap the count is 258 counts per minute. With paper it is 255. With 5 mm of aluminium it is 19.

(a) Work out the corrected count rate with paper and with the aluminium. [2 marks]

(b) State the type of radiation from Q and give a reason. [2 marks]

(c) State two safety precautions the teacher should take. [2 marks]

Model answer

(a) With paper: 255 − 18 = 237 counts per minute. (1) With aluminium: 19 − 18 = 1 count per minute. (1)

(b) Beta. (1) Paper hardly reduces the count but a few mm of aluminium stops almost all of it. (1)

(c) Any two from: use tongs; point the source away from people; keep the time of use as short as possible; store it in a lead-lined box. (1 each)

Exam tip

Correct for background before you compare readings. In (b), quote the change in numbers, such as 237 falling to 1, to earn the reason mark.

Test Your Knowledge
Chat to Physics tutor